Episode 36

5 Things to Know about the Open Source Investigations and Ethics

In the second installation of our new three-part OSINT series here on Adversity Quotient, we explore 5 Things to Know About Ethics and Open Source Investigation with guest speaker Dr. Giancarlo Fiorella, Director of Research and Training at Bellingcat and assistant professor at Utrecht University’s Global Justice Investigations Lab. Dr. Fiorella and host, Director at CASIS-Vancouver and Chief Operating Officer, Sam David discuss the distinctions between open-source investigation and OSINT, and what researchers should keep in mind while engaging with the field.


Guest |  Dr. Giancarlo Fiorella. Giancarlo is the Director of Research and Training at Bellingcat, an organization that conducts investigations using digital open source information. He is also an assistant professor at the Utrecht University’s Global Justice Investigations Lab. He has a PhD from the University of Toronto, where his doctoral research focused on protest policing by non-state actors in Venezuela.

Host | Sam David is Chief Operating Officer with CASIS-Vancouver, as well as Production Coordinator for the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare and Editorial Consultant for the UBC Journal of Political Studies. His research interests lie in Critical Security and Intelligence Studies, with emphasis on violent transnational social movements, identity-based conflict, and the interaction of ontological security, social norms and narratives, and neurobiology. At present his research is focused on conceptions of self, nostalgia, and imagination in violent transnational social movements.

5 Key Points:

  1. Open source investigations at Bellingcat: Dr. Fiorella emphasized that Bellingcat prefers the use of the term “open source investigations” rather than “OSINT”, as research at Bellingcat is distinctly in the civil sphere, akin to journalism. It is therefore outside the law enforcement and government-related connotations of OSINT. He described the environment at Bellingcat as being similar to a graduate school department, in that the organization is centered around a community of researchers, each with their own specializations and individual interests. Dr. Fiorella stated that Bellingcat recently completed a strategy review process, where members collectively assessed the organization’s history and research to determine key topics to focus on in the years ahead. These topics include contemporary conflict monitoring, environmental research, financial monitoring, and online extremist movements.
  2. How should researchers approach getting involved in the field: Dr. Fiorella emphasized the need to ‘demystify’ the field of open-source investigation, where there is a misconception that there is a high barrier of entry to involvement and developing skill sets in this space. Rather, tools and resources are accessible online that allow for individuals without specialized or formal education to learn and become involved in open-source investigations. Dr. Fiorella further noted that academia has developed in recent years in regards to literature on open-source research, creating more opportunities for scholars to engage formally with the space.
  3. On maintaining ethical practices in open source investigation: Dr. Fiorella explained that purpose-built ethical frameworks for open-source investigation did not exist early in Bellingcat’s history, leading researchers at Bellingcat to look towards newsroom and journalism ethics, which continue to broadly influence the organization’s ethical guidelines. Dr. Fiorella also pointed to the Berkeley Protocol on Digital Open-Source Investigations as a resource for researchers and organizations in the open-source investigation space to consult regarding ethical guidelines.
  4. Protecting researchers at Bellingcat: Dr. Fiorella noted that where Bellingcat often engages in high profile investigations, such as those related to state actors, the organization places a high emphasis on the safety of its researchers. He raised the example of a Bellingcat investigation that discovered responsibility on the part of the Russian state for the shoot-down of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 in 2014, and subsequent research which exposed Russian espionage campaigns in Western Europe. Dr. Fiorella explained that Bellingcat has implemented several practices regarding virtual and physical security to protect the safety of the organization’s members, including the use of VPNs, and travel safety protocols.
  5. Privacy rights and open-source investigation: Dr. Fiorella described how organizations and individuals in the field must remain conscious of both laws and regulations regarding privacy. He stated that as Bellingcat is registered in the Netherlands, it is compliant with the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Dr. Fiorella emphasized that open-source investigation can call attention to individuals in a way that may place them at risk; something that individuals and organizations operating in the field must take into consideration. For example, a practice was established to exclude incident content from being published if it contained identifiable features or information that could put an individual, recorder, or bystander in danger. 

References:

Berkeley Protocol on Digital Open Source Investigations: A practical guide on the effective use of digital open source and information in investigating violations of international criminal, Human Rights and Humanitarian Law. United Nations Human Rights Office Of The High Commissioner. (2022, January 3). https://www.ohchr.org/en/publications/policy-and-methodological-publications/berkeley-protocol-digital-open-source

Fiorella, G. (2023, September 18). Notes from the Digital Field: Ethical Dilemmas in Open Source Research. bellingcat. https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/2023/09/18/notes-from-the-digital-field-ethical-dilemmas-in-open-source-research/

Lee, T., Koltai , K., & Fiorella, G. (2024, April 25). Oshit: Seven deadly sins of bad open source research. bellingcat. https://www.bellingcat.com/resources/2024/04/25/oshit-seven-deadly-sins-of-bad-open-source-research/

MH17 The Open Source Evidence. (2015). bellingcat. https://www.bellingcat.com/app/uploads/2015/10/MH17-The-Open-Source-Evidence-EN.pdf

Wolfword, B. (2023, September 14). What is GDPR, the EU’s new Data Protection Law? GDPR.eu. https://gdpr.eu/what-is-gdpr/

Recent Posts

For media inquiries, please contact sbergler@casisvancouver.ca.

For research inquiries, please contact ckelshall@casisvancouver.ca.

Categories