Episode 35

5 Things to Know about Current and Future Practices of OSINT

In the first installation of our new three-part OSINT series here on Adversity Quotient, we explore 5 Things to Know About the Current and Future Practices of OSINT with guest speaker Justin Peden, founder of ‘The Intel Crab’; an online open-source intelligence aggregator focused on observing the War in Ukraine. Mr. Peden and host, Assistant Executive Officer of CASIS-Vancouver, Evan Kryski, discuss OSINT practitioner perspectives on a multitude of topics, including ethics and technology. 


Guest | Justin Peden. Using commercial satellite data, unique geolocation techniques, and direct translation skills, Mr. Peden has documented several key events since the Invasion of Ukraine back in 2022. Along with several other large accounts on X (formerly known as Twitter), he forms the backbone of a growing collection of online hobbyists who spend large amounts of both time and resources documenting conflicts otherwise far too far away to ever examine in great detail.
Host |Evan Kryski is the Deputy Executive Officer of Research with CASIS Vancouver. His research interests lie in exploring the intricacies and intersectionality of extremism and radicalization, soft violence, nuclear proliferation, deradicalization,hybrid warfare, and identity based conflict. With further work in the field of intelligence, he hopes to assist in the development of strategies to better analyze the multifaceted and ever changing nature of the Canadian security landscape.

5 Key Points:

  1. Ethical considerations of OSINT: Mr. Justin Peden emphasized that researchers need to take into account the need for impartiality, transparency, and consideration for real-world safety implications of resharing open-source intelligence (OSINT) content to large online followings. He noted that new programs to allow for creator monetization on social media platforms, such as X (formally known as Twitter), can undermine non-profit-centric approaches in the field of OSINT, and this has contributed to an increase in low-quality clickbait content. With the increasing prevalence of AI, there is a need for transparency regarding the use of AI tools and plugins in OSINT workflows to ensure that methodologies and content can be checked for accuracy. He also emphasized the critical need for OSINT researchers to self-moderate in regard to the time appropriateness of sharing and distributing OSINT information, noting that he has personally sat on discoveries for days and even weeks out of consideration of possible real-world harm. 
  2. Emerging trends and technologies shaping the future of OSINT: Mr. Peden acknowledged the increasing prevalence of AI tools, where many significant innovations have occurred since 2023. In particular, AI tools and plugins are streamlining OSINT workflows and automating tasks such as geolocation, which have traditionally been done manually with great care. On the other hand, Mr. Peden illustrated how AI is also posing new challenges to OSINT practitioners, raising the example of the October 7th attacks on Israel and its aftermath, where fabricated and misleading AI-generated content related to the conflict circulated on social media at an unprecedented scale. He also noted that social media itself is continuing to redefine the OSINT space, with the emergence of large following and often anonymous OSINT creators on platforms like X, as characterized by Peden’s own @IntelCrab account.    
  3. Primary OSINT sources: Mr. Peden emphasized the value for practitioners of immersing themselves and connecting directly with local communities and sources through mediums like social media. He recalled how his own journey towards creating @IntelCrab was started by connecting to and aggregating information shared from local communities and individuals affected by the war in Donbas on X. Mr. Peden also noted that providing context and transparency are key principles OSINT practitioners need to emphasize. Context should be provided in relation to directly translated content, and the biases of primary sources should be clearly stated where information from them is reshared. Additionally, claims and reports of events or attacks, especially on platforms like X, should be verified through multiple sources like satellite and commercial imagery. 
  4. Balancing timely updates and the need for ensuring accuracy and authenticity of information: Mr. Peden emphasized that with real time platforms such as X, practitioners should not focus on being first but rather on due diligence to ensure that information is correct. Mr. Peden argued that with the stream of information on such platforms being constant and unending, by nature, OSINT collectors will always be operating by some form of delay anyway, no matter how attentive they are. He also noted that where the public and even traditional media outlets face challenges related to false and misleading content on social media platforms like X, especially in the immediate aftermath of a crisis or disaster, OSINT practitioners are needed to fulfill the role of fact-checkers and myth busters.  
  5. The Evolution of the OSINT Community: Mr. Peden stated that platforms such as X that allow for large followings and community engagement are unique in providing opportunities for community-led self-correction where errors occur, which often smaller following platforms like blogs usually do not provide. He emphasized that OSINT work is primarily collaborative and non-organic, where practitioners rely on collecting existing information rather than producing new content and verifying that information through collaboration with the broader OSINT community. He noted that over the last five years in particular, the OSINT community has significantly grown from its hobby-centric origins, with the emergence of large following accounts like @IntelCrab, which in some cases have allowed practitioners to establish careers from their work. Mr. Peden concluded by advising young people entering the field of OSINT that the earlier they can accept and maintain the mindset that they are learners and not experts, the better off they will be. 

References:

Ghioni, R., Taddeo, M., & Floridi, L. (2023). Open source intelligence and AI: A systematic review of the GELSI literature. AI & Society: Journal of Knowledge Culture and Communication, 28(3). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-023-01628-x 

Peden, J. @IntelCrab. (n.d.). Tweets. Retrieved June 10, 2024, from https://x.com/IntelCrab. 

Salerno-Garthwaite, A. (2022, October 12). OSINT in Ukraine: Civilians in the kill chain and the information space. Global Defence Technology. https://defence.nridigital.com/global_defence_technology_oct22/osint_in_ukraine