5 Things to Know about Polarization and Identity Politics in the U.S.
The latest episode of the Adversity Quotient Podcast explores 5 Things to Know About Polarization and Identity Politics in the U.S. with guest speaker Dr. George Hawley, Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Alabama. Alongside CASIS Vancouver host, Sam Allen, Dr. Hawley delves into the rise of the American Conservative movement, its relationship with identity politics, the relationship between public opinion and identity politics and the threat of identity based violence in the run up to the U.S. elections.


5 Key Points:
- American Conservatism
Dr. Hawley differentiated between Conservatism as a broad ideology or a personal belief, and the American Conservative movement known as Fusionism. Dr. Hawley defined American conservatism as the movement that developed after the Second World War with journalists and scholars such as William F Buckley, Barry Goldwater, and within the renowned publication, National Review. This movement often adopts the economic views of Libertarians and has allowed Conservatives and Libertarians to collaborate. American Conservatism, according to Dr. Hawley, openly accepts the classical liberal tradition and key liberals, such as John Stuart Mill. However, it retains that a population held together by more traditional Conservative principles, such as virtue, is needed to maintain individual liberty. - Conservatives’ Historical Relationship with Identity Politics
Dr. Hawley argued that Conservatives have historically disagreed with identity politics, yet have consistently used identity politics for political gain. Conservatives maintain that identity politics reduces individuals to tribal groups and instincts rather than rational free agents, yet this belief is commonly contradicted across strains of conservatism. Dr. Hawley used the example of Feminism, whereby Libertarian strains of Conservatism did not object to the aims of feminism but believed it was a government-caused issue that would be approached over time by free market structure. However, traditional Conservatives, Dr. Hawley argued, rejected feminism by using identity politics. - Identity Politics and Public Opinion
Dr. Hawley framed Conservatism’s objection to identity politics as fundamentally hypocritical since partisanship and identity are inextricably linked. He elaborated that identity is a key component of the ‘self’ and contrary to Conservative political thought, we are not rational utility maximisers, but rather a product of underlying identity. Dr. Hawley highlighted that his research has shown social identity is a key cause of our party loyalty; each individual values identities differently and this is what determines our political identification. The underlying identities such as class, religion or race make us associate political parties with ourselves. - The Growing Relationship Between Identity and Public Opinion
Dr. Hawley contends that party identification is becoming a key component of group-based antagonisms. Dr. Hawley highlighted that whilst polarization related to policy issues has remained constant, polarization based on partisan identity has grown considerably. Partisan identity, rather than policy issues, have caused the current negative trends in U.S. politics as party identification becomes a greater part of individual identity. - Identity Politics and Violence
Dr. Hawley predicted that mass violence based on partisanship or identity is unlikely during the U.S. elections, stating that government response to identity-based attacks should not be driven by a threat inflation, such as that during the so-called ‘War on Terror’. Conversely, Dr. Hawley predicted that violence will likely be made up of small groups or lone wolf attacks inspired by an almost cult-like following of Donald Trump. The use of white grievance and Christian nationalism by the Republican Party is a worrying trend, but nevertheless, Dr. Hawley remarked that the U.S. has been divided far more historically such as during the 1960s and survived.
References:
Hawley, G (2022) Conservatism in a Divided America. University of Notre Dame Press.
Hawley, G (2021), ‘The Stillborn revolution: The Failure of right wing populism in the US’ in Global Resurgence of the Right, Gisela Pereyra Doval, Gastón Souroujon, Routledge.
Thompson, J., & Hawley, G. (2021). Does the Alt-Right still matter? An examination of Alt-Right influence between 2016 and 2018. Nations and Nationalism, 27(4), 1165–1180. https://doi.org/10.1111/nana.12736
Hawley, G., Marcy, R. T., & Zúquete, J. P. (2023). Examining the performance and political influence of far right vanguard leaders: the case of Jonathan Bowden. Journal of Political Ideologies, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/13569317.2023.2219211
Thompson, S. K. (2024). POLARIZATION AND INTERVENTION-BASED P/CVE PROGRAMS IN CANADA. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 6(3), 105–109. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v6i3.6370
Padda, K. (2020). Fake News on Twitter in 2016 U.S. Presidential Election: A Quantitative Approach. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 3(2), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v3i2.2374
Recent Posts
- News: Volume 6, Issue 1 of the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare Has Launched
- 2022 CASIS Annual Symposium
- October 2022 Digital Roundtable: “Predictive Policing and the Techno-Social Implications of Algorithmic Decision-making” with Dr. Ryan Prox
- News: “Understanding Open-Source Intelligence” Course at uOttawa’s Professional Development Institute
- News: CASIS Vancouver Partnership with the Canadian Police Knowledge Network
For media inquiries, please contact sbergler@casisvancouver.ca.
For research inquiries, please contact ckelshall@casisvancouver.ca.
