AQ Episode 29

5 Things To Know About Persecuting Terrorism in Canada

Guest |  Dr. Michael Nesbitt is an Associate Professor of Law at the University of Calgary, Faculty of Law, where he teaches, researches, and practices in the areas of national security and anti-terrorism law, criminal law, and the law of autonomous sanctions. Before joining the Faculty of Law Michael worked as a lawyer and diplomat for Global Affairs Canada, as a lawyer for Canada’s Department of Justice, and as a lawyer for the United Nations at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia in the Hague.

Host | Maxwell Gardner is an Executive with CASIS-Vancouver with a diverse set of interests that converge into a creative research mind to cultivate innovation. With hands-on experience working on small scale volunteer projects abroad, over 5 years of experience as a carpenter on large projects in Canada, and a background in International Relations and Languages. Max’s research interests focus on International Development & Security in the Anthropocene and Translations Studies. Max hopes to assist in creating conversations between Canadian institutions, agencies, and the private sector that strengthen cooperation on transnational issues.

5 Key Points:

  1. Dr. Nesbitt began by outlining that there is no single definition of terrorism in Canada, but rather terrorist activities and terrorist groups are specifically defined in the Canadian criminal code. As terrorist groups are essentially defined as groups which engage in terrorist activities, the definitions of terrorist activities are fundamental to understanding terrorism in Canadian law. 
  2. Dr. Nesbitt explained that there are two main sources for the definitions of terrorist activities in the Canadian law: 1) internal treaties that relate to forms of terrorism, like the Hague Hijacking Convention, and 2) a set of three clauses in Canadian law, implying that terrorist activities must be significant in consequence, must be carried out for a political purpose, and must be motivated by political, ideological or religious reason.
  3. Dr. Nesbitt observed that terrorism provisions have existed in Canada for a relatively short period of time, only being added to the criminal code after 9/11. Consequently many areas of law relating to terrorism in Canada remain unclear. He added that in particular, there have been no public statements, and very few judicial pronouncements on the third clause defining terrorist activities.
  4. Noticeably, terrorism offenses are relatively less serious offenses in the Canadian criminal code according to Dr. Nesbitt.The maximum sentencing for terrorist offenses tend to be in the range of 10-14 years, closer to the indictment penalty for criminal mischief than for murder.  In practice however, he added that individuals tend to face multiple terrorism charges at once, often collectively resulting in long terms of imprisonment. 
  5. Dr. Nesbitt expanded on a legal challenge relating to the transnational nature of terrorism; terrorist groups are often international with members residing across multiple countries around the world. In practice this means the infiltration of terrorist groups often takes place in online spaces like chat rooms, which imposes limitations on what information on individuals can be practically collected.

Relevant Articles:

  1. Terrorism, Criminal Code (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-46)
  2. Nesbitt, M., & Hagg, D. (2020). An empirical study of terrorism prosecutions in Canada: Elucidating the elements of the offences. Alberta Law Review, 57(3), 595–648. https://doi.org/10.29173/alr2590
  3. Nesbitt, M., Oxoby, R., & and Potier, M,. (2019). Terrorism Sentencing Decisions in Canada Since 2001: Shifting Away From the Fundamental Principle and Towards Cognitive Biases. UBC Law Review
  4. Nesbitt, M., & Hagg, D. (2019). “Prosecuting Terrorism in Canada: Elucidating the Elements of the Offences”.  Alberta Law Review. 
  5. Gurski, P. (2023). WHERE IS TERRORISM GOING AND ARE CANADIAN AGENCIES PREPARED TO CONFRONT IT?. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 5(3), 157–160. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v5i3.5188