AQ Episode 31

5 Things To Know About Misinformation and Disinformation

Guest |  Prof. Kelshall is  currently is the President of the Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies (CASIS) Vancouver, the Founder/Director of the Canadian Centre for Contemporary Conflict Research (C4), and Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare (JICW). She is also an instructor at the Justice Institute of British Columbia (JIBC) where she delivers courses on Structured Analytical Techniques and Open-Source Intelligence and also teaches at the British Columbia Institute for Technology (BCIT) in Canada where she delivers lectures on forensic technology, artificial intelligence, machine learning, new models and approaches for dealing with crime, and conceptualizing the nature and character of contemporary conflict within society. She has lectured at the University of Buckingham, University of Sussex, and Simon Fraser University in the United Kingdom where she delivered courses on intelligence psychology, understanding the psychology behind terrorist actors, international relations, and intelligence failures in the last 20 years. As an instructor with University of Ottawa’s Professional Development Institute, Candyce delivers micro-credential courses on Open-Source Intelligence and Structured Analytical Techniques.

Host | Sam David is Chief Operating Officer with CASIS-Vancouver, as well as Production Coordinator for the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare and Editorial Consultant for the UBC Journal of Political Studies. His research interests lie in Critical Security and Intelligence Studies, with emphasis on violent transnational social movements, identity-based conflict, and the interaction of ontological security, social norms and narratives, and neurobiology. At present his research is focused on conceptions of self, nostalgia, and imagination in violent transnational social movements.

5 Key Points:

  1. Presently, misinformation and disinformation is one of the most pressing issues that professionals in the national security space need to understand and address, where there is a real and present danger of community division exacerbated by false information transforming into the threat of kinetic violence stated Professor Kelshall. It is therefore critical that our understandings of misinformation and disinformation evolve beyond simply recognizing their characteristics, to understanding the implications and motivations that explain their appearance in social discourse. Describing misinformation and disinformation is not enough, she stressed; in order to move beyond the ability to solely recognize these threats and to effectively address them, we need definitions, and that by nature requires an understanding of their role and purpose.
  2. Professor Kelshall said that the role and purpose of misinformation is to telegraph a particular worldview in order to widen the group of people who share an identity derived from stances on divisive issues. There is a common misconception that individuals share misinformation simply because they are mistaken or uneducated about the topic at hand. Whether or not the information is true is not actually relevant, rather people share misinformation because it conforms to and reinforces a worldview they already had, explained Prof. Kelshall. She explained that the root motivation for sharing misinformation is not ignorance, but social and political and frustration, the quantity of misinformation circulating in public discourse directly correlates to the increased kinetic threat of violence. 
  3. The role and purpose of disinformation is to deliberately weaponize grievances to create polarization in a community or population, said Prof. Kelshall. Disinformation is able to take root in a population because that population is already susceptible to agreeing with narratives that conform to their existing worldviews. Where disinformation and misinformation center around how someone constructs their own identity, it is difficult to try to counter these narratives with just facts and correct information. She expanded that an understanding of information integrity when individuals engage with media content is critical to preventing these narratives from taking hold in the first place. This means critically assessing the sources of content, the possible motivation behind them, and being cognizant of clearly judgmental and grievance centric language that are designed to cater to specific worldviews.
  4. Prof. Kelshall stated that there are multiple forms of disinformation, including hate-based disinformation which is designed to incite hatred and conflict between different communities within a state and state-based disinformation, which is designed to delegitimize and reduce the trust of a state’s institutions and government. There is also economic disinformation that is intended to cause financial harm to communities through means such as targeting companies and trade relationships. In some cases, she pointed out that there are also hybrid forms of disinformation that combine the characteristics of hate, state and economic forms.  
  5. Misinformation and disinformation pose a risk to the human infrastructure of a society; the shared values and relationships people in state have with each other, being damaged and destroyed by the exploitation and amplification of existing legtimate greviences, said Prof. Kelshall. Disinformation therefore is the weaponization of feelings and beliefs, to target the human infrastructure of a state in order to cripple and divide it from within. Where transnational activist networks that spread misinformation and disinformation can operate across borders and mobilize on the basis of grievance politics, she explained that a state’s human infrastructure is not protected by borders. 

Relevant Articles:

Kelshall, C. (2024). Blurring Boundaries: War and Violence in a New Era. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 6(3), 100–104. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v6i3.6416

Huey, L. (2022). The Implications of Misinformation for Public Order Policing. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 5(2), 204–208. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v5i2.5071

Kelshall, C. (2019). Violent Transnational Social Movements and their Impact On Contemporary Social Conflict. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 1(3), 27–42. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v1i3.840

Nikoula, D. (2023). Unraveling the Kremlin’s Disinformation Strategy. Information Integrity Lab, University of Ottawa Professional Development Institute. 

Kelshall, C., & Archutowski, N. (2021). Concept of Soft Violence in Critical Security Studies. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 4(2), 103–108. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v4i2.3755

Kieth D. Willett. 2022. Total War. In Disruption, Ideation and Innovation for Defense and Security. Springer, Cham.

Verjee, Z., Kelshall C. (2024) Mis/Dis and The Newsroom of the Future. The Rundown Studio, Substack. https://rundownstudio.substack.com/p/misdis-and-the-newsroom-of-the-future