Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies Vancouver
AQ Episode 32
5 Things To Know About Terrorism VS. Extremism
Guest | Prof. Kelshall is currently is the President of the Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies (CASIS) Vancouver, the Founder/Director of the Canadian Centre for Contemporary Conflict Research (C4), and Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare (JICW). She is also an instructor at the Justice Institute of British Columbia (JIBC) where she delivers courses on Structured Analytical Techniques and Open-Source Intelligence and also teaches at the British Columbia Institute for Technology (BCIT) in Canada where she delivers lectures on forensic technology, artificial intelligence, machine learning, new models and approaches for dealing with crime, and conceptualizing the nature and character of contemporary conflict within society. She has lectured at the University of Buckingham, University of Sussex, and Simon Fraser University in the United Kingdom where she delivered courses on intelligence psychology, understanding the psychology behind terrorist actors, international relations, and intelligence failures in the last 20 years. As an instructor with University of Ottawa’s Professional Development Institute, Candyce delivers micro-credential courses on Open-Source Intelligence and Structured Analytical Techniques.
Host | Sam David is Chief Operating Officer with CASIS-Vancouver, as well as Production Coordinator for the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare and Editorial Consultant for the UBC Journal of Political Studies. His research interests lie in Critical Security and Intelligence Studies, with emphasis on violent transnational social movements, identity-based conflict, and the interaction of ontological security, social norms and narratives, and neurobiology. At present his research is focused on conceptions of self, nostalgia, and imagination in violent transnational social movements.
5 Key Points:
Terrorists are not extremists, soft vs spectacle violence : The updated UK definition of extremism focuses on the promotion or advancement of ideology using violence, hatred, or intolerance, with the aim of negating or destroying fundamental rights and freedoms or undermining, overturning, or replacing the liberal parliamentary democracy of the UK. Prof Kelshall notes this definition requires a clarification between the terms “Terrorism” and “Extremism”. The former is referent to a group who performs spectacle violence against the state. Where the latter is a network of identities and grievances who interact in a way that is coercive and intends to do to the outgroup through soft violence.
Terrorism is closed and clandestine whereas extremism tries to widen in the general community : Prof. Kelshall emphasized the limitations of focusing on singular ideology, and noted that the majority of extremist actors studied over the past seven years support multiple ideologies and form a basket of grievances. Yet violence remains consistent across extremist and terrorist groups whose means and methods are distinct. She noted that the UK’s definition focuses on ideology but needs to go further is addressing the basket of grievances impacting the multiple identities assumed by individuals turning towards extremism. Extremist aims to widen its influence in the general community and engages with the public discourse through soft violence, explained Prof. Kelshall. Distinctly, terrorism operates under closed and clandestine operations that are meant to generate spectacle violence in order to shape public perception and support for their cause.
Extremism uses soft violence, which is not yet criminal but exerts power and harm to the outgroups : Prof Kelshall stated that the difference between terrorism and extremism lies in their approaches to violence and radicalization. Terrorism, characterized by single-issue actors engaging in spectacle violence which targets the state to coerce a change aligned with their cause. Terrorism is generally a more esoteric grouping that does not publicly engage outside of their violent activities. In contrast, extremists have a more exoteric approach that is motivated to generate camaraderie based on identity. Both terrorist and extremist interactions produce exoteric and esoteric reactions within and outside their group, the extremist nexus tends to be more heterogeneously represented in terms of public engagement with their grievances.
Terrorism has a single grievance whereas Extremism has multiple identities : Making the distinction between terrorism and extremism is crucial as it informs mitigation or approach based on the understanding built into the nomenclature. She explained that understanding the differences between the objective of terrorism and extremism and how they operate to challenge the state is fundamental in creating effective strategies to stop or limit these activities.
Extremism discussions can be had at a kitchen table, discourse based : The name defines the approach to dealing with terrorism and extremism, with terrorism often characterized by closed and clandestine activities. To emphasize how easy extremism dialogue can occur, Prof kelshall stated that discussions can occur at a kitchen table, based on discourse that is passed through signs and symbols to reflect certain views of the world. The public nature of extremism is distinctly different from terrorism as it can be publicly communicated and difficult to distinguish the subtle harm embedded within the messaging.
Relevant Articles:
Kelshall, C., & Archutowski, N. (2021). Concept of Soft Violence in Critical Security Studies. The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 4(2), 103–108. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v4i2.3755
Kelshall, C. (2021). Soft Violence, Social Radicalisation, and Violent Transnational Social Movements (VTSMs). The Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare, 3(3), 146–153. https://doi.org/10.21810/jicw.v3i3.2800
Cram, I. (2019). Countering terrorism through limits on inciteful speech: Principles and problems. In Extremism, Free Speech and Counter-Terrorism Law and Policy (1st ed., Vol. 1, pp. 8–33). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429469091-2
Koehler D. Betraying the Cause?: Side-Switching and Violent Extremism. In: From Traitor to Zealot: Exploring the Phenomenon of Side-Switching in Extremism and Terrorism. Cambridge University Press; 2021:1-52.
Rakhshandehroo, S., Duits, N., Bergman, D., Verkes, R.-J., & Kempes, M. (2023). Psychopathology in female offenders of terrorism and violent extremism: a systematic review. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 14, 1123243–1123243. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1123243