Analysis of Blood and Honour

ANALYSIS OF BLOOD & HONOUR AND COMBAT 18 TERRORIST ENTITY DESIGNATION

The Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies (CASIS) Vancouver acknowledges and supports the Canadian government’s motion to classify the groups Blood & Honour and Combat 18 (C18), as terrorist organizations. In light of these efforts to address the threat of Right-Wing Extremism (RWE), CASIS Vancouver’s research on RWE and Violent Transnational Social Movements (VTSM) provides a deeper analysis of the implications of these actions for both current and future threats from VTSMs. Our findings suggest that these groups only represent a small part of what is a larger, transnational movement “centered on the preservation and protection of a cultural identity.” (Kelshall, 2018). To read our findings, click here.

CASIS Vancouver’s research teams have developed the notion of Violent Transnational Social Movements (VTSM) to classify identity-based causes and collectives as part of an identity struggle in the context of a larger movement. In our support for the Canadian government, we wish to provide context and analysis of the decision to designate Blood & Honour and C18 as terrorist groups. Both of these groups provide clear examples of the characteristics of VTSMs. VTSMs are massively mobilized identity-based groups across three or more countries that perpetuate the importance of protecting their values and culture over others. They purport to fight against actors and ideas which are perceived to threaten their existence. One of the key deterministic factors of a VSTM are that these movements are arguably unconcerned with the authority of the state and state institutions. Unlike criminal or terrorist organizations, VTSMs have no interest in territorial gains but are focused on cultural gains. This indifference to the government allows for VTSMs, their ideas, and culture to cross borders, arguably creating an international security threat. The second factor is that VSTMs are movements based on identity, common values and tribal bonds and therefore can be made up of multiple indirectly related identity-based movements (Kelshall, 2018). For more information, please refer to “Violent Transnational Social Movements” by CM Kelshall.

The designation of these organizations as terrorist groups have significant implications for RWE in Canada given the Canadian government’s previous reluctance in acknowledging the nature and scope of the threat (Public Safety Canada, 2018). The additions of Blood and Honour and Combat 18 represent a significant departure from previous findings and responses to the threat of RWE. Following recent RWE incidents such as the 2019 Christchurch Mosque shootings and the 2018 Toronto Van Attack, there has been an urgent need to both identify and address the domestic consequences of the global threat of RWE (Cain, 2018). This response by the Canadian government acknowledges the severity of the previously unchecked growth of RWE and its increasing threat to national security by placing these groups in the same category as groups such as Al Qaeda and its offshoots as well as the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps’ Qods Force. The designation of these RWE groups as terrorist entities arguably establishes the willingness of the Canadian government to react to RWE outside of law enforcement approach which has traditionally hindered government responses (Ball, 2012). The significance of this milestone should not be underestimated as the designation of these groups as terrorist entities sets a newfound precedent in addressing both current and future RWE groups. With this novel scope to designate RWE groups as terrorist threats, the Canadian government can thus implement policies and restrictions which allow “the property of its members…[to]…be seized by the government” as well as criminalize participation or contributions, both direct or indirect to the activities of designated terrorist entities (Lamoureux, 2019).   

The Canadian government has taken decisive action in classifying Blood & Honour and C18 as threats to Canadian security. However, CASIS research suggests that VTSMs, rather than individual groups should be considered national security threats given their ability to transmit ideas, narratives, and culture. While these steps in addressing RWE should be considered significant, there is still an urgent need to address the underlying factors that create and facilitate these VTSMS. This means going beyond simply confronting kinetic activities but addressing the soft violence that can be just as harmful. Other groups such as the Three Percenters, Soldiers of Odin, and The Aryan Guard are active participants in the larger movement. By labeling Blood & Honour and C18 as terrorist organizations, the Government of Canada has taken an important step in combating RWE, but further steps will need to include discussing these groups as separate parts of an international and global identity-based, violent movement.

ABOUT CASIS VANCOUVER

The Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies (CASIS) Vancouver is a non-partisan, voluntary organization dedicated to facilitating the handshake between practitioners and academics. The mandate of CASIS is to empower and enhance research, discussion, and engagement with issues of national security and intelligence. CASIS achieves its mandate, mission, and objectives by employing three pillars; discussion, dissemination, and research.

Discussion is accomplished via our monthly roundtable events, special and joint events, and annual conferences. 

Dissemination of original research and expert reports is accomplished via the Journal of Conflict, Intelligence, and Warfare (JICW). CASIS Publications are disseminated to various national agencies and organizations. 

Original research that CASIS conducts within the fields of security and intelligence is designed to bring awareness to possible emerging threats to Canada and further encourages the study of intelligence and security. CASIS Vancouver currently has 2 key research projects; Violent Transnational Social Movements, which encompasses research on Right Wing-Extremism, and the National Cyber Research project.

CASIS publications include two intelligence tradecraft work books on structured analytical techniques (SATs); Accidental Power, a collection of essays examining the rise of violent non-state actors and their rejection of the Westphalian notion of the state; and PREPARED, a Program to Educate on the Prevention and Reduction of Extremist Discourse aimed at equipping youth educators  with preventative knowledge and tools to identify and deal with youth radicalization. CASIS also publishes the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict, and Warfare; a biannual peer-reviewed journal with a special edition published following the West Coast Security Conference. The JICW’s current issue focuses on the influence of non-state actors on state legitimacy.  

For media inquiries, please contact sbergler@casisvancouver.ca

References

Anti-Racist Canada. (2010, November 28). Aryan Guard is Now Blood & Honour. Or Not? Retrieved from https://anti-racistcanada.blogspot.com/2010/11/aryan-guard-is-now-blood-honour-or-not.html#more

Anti-Racist Canada. (2011, December 09). MSM Confusing Blood and Honour Factions. Retrieved from http://anti-racistcanada.blogspot.com/2011/12/msm-confusing-blood-and-honour-factions.html

Anti-Racist Canada. (2018, December 09). Canadian Connection To Man Who Murdered Heather Heyer. Retrieved from https://anti-racistcanada.blogspot.com/2018/12/canadian-connection-to-man-who-murdered.html

Anti-Racist Canada. (2018, December 25). Yellow Vest Extremists: Two Case Studies From Edmonton and Calgary. Retrieved from http://anti-racistcanada.blogspot.com/2018/12/yellow-vest-extremists-two-case-studies.html#more

Anti-Racist Canada. (2019, May 14). Edson, AB Hate Crime Suspect Identified; Linked to Blood & Honour in Alberta. Retrieved from http://anti-racistcanada.blogspot.com/2019/05/edson-ab-hate-crime-suspect-identified.html

Anti-Racist Canada. (2019, January 01). Follow-Up on Dara “Nazi Mom” Graham and the Reactionary Yellow Vests. Retrieved from http://anti-racistcanada.blogspot.com/2019/01/follow-up-on-dara-nazi-mom-graham-and.html

Ball, D. P. (2012, March 20). Neo-Nazi group’s racist hate crimes condoned by public apathy and silence: Police. Retrieved from https://www.vancouverobserver.com/politics/2012/03/19/racist-hate-crimes-condoned-public-apathy-and-silence-police

Ball, D. P. (2013, October 10). Neo-Nazis Are Attacking Anti-Racist Activists in Calgary. Retrieved from https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/gq8pz7/neo-nazis-are-attacking-anti-racist-activists-in-calgary

Blais, T. (2013, May 13). Calgary white supremacist given 13 months for having a shotgun. Retrieved from https://edmontonsun.com/2013/05/13/calgary-white-supremacist-given-13-months-for-having-a-shotgun/wcm/c509461f-a9da-4e54-afec-0389fee60bab

Blood and Honour. (n.d.). A History of the Blood & Honour Movement. Retrieved from https://www.28brotherhood.com/history

Cain, P. (2018). Expert traces link between violent online alt-right fantasies and real-world attacks. Retrieved from https://globalnews.ca/news/4167152/toronto-van-attack-incel-alek-minassian-violence/

CASIS Vancouver. (2018, November 18). Lexicon. Retrieved from https://casisvancouver.ca/1_19_fifth-generation-warfare.html/publications/lexicon/

CBC. (2010, November 09). Calgary anti-racism activists’ home invaded | CBC News. Retrieved from https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-anti-racism-activists-home-invaded-1.902197

Balgord (2017, December 4). Blood & Honour, a violent neo-Nazi group, delivers a “It’s Okay To Be White” flyer to a Calgary anti-fascist activist – and nobody else on his block. Same activist was the victim of a Blood and Honour-linked home-invasion and assault with hammers in 2010. [Twitter Post]. Retrieved from https://twitter.com/ebalgord/status/937790060514168832

Humphreys, A. (2012, April 18). Violent racist gang expands into Edmonton. Retrieved from https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/violent-racist-gang-expands-into-edmonton

Hutchinson, B. (2011, December 09). Blood and Honour ‘white supremacists’ charged over string of assaults on minorities. Retrieved from https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/white-supremacists-who-allegedly-set-fire-to-filipino-man-charged-over-hate-crimes

Kelshall, C. M. (2018). Violent Transnational Social Movements and Their Impact on Contemporary Social Conflict. In Accidental Power: How Non-State Actors Hijacked Legitimacy and Re-Shaped the International System (pp. 19-33). Burnaby, BC: Simon Fraser University Library.

Lamoureux, M. (2019, June 26). Canada Adds Far-Right Groups to Terror Watch List for First Time. Retrieved from https://www.vice.com/en_ca/article/8xz77k/canada-adds-far-right-groups-to-terror-watch-list-for-first-time

Montreal-Antifascist. (2018, November 17). A Key La Meute Militant Founds a Neo-Nazi Organization . . . Then Changes His Mind a Few Hours Later! Retrieved from https://montreal-antifasciste.info/en/2018/11/17/a-key-la-meute-militant-founds-a-neo-nazi-organization-then-changes-his-mind-a-few-hours-later/

Public Safety Canada. (2018). 2018 Public Report on the Terrorist Threat to Canada (3rd ed., Rep.).

Roth, P. (2012, April 18). White supremacists arrested over Edmonton racial attack. Retrieved from https://edmontonsun.com/2012/04/17/white-supremacists-arrested-over-edmonton-racial-attack/wcm/4ea856ca-54f8-498c-8c4f-83b5df27441a

Wingrove, J. (2011, March 18). Calgary’s in-your-face neo-Nazis take to the streets. Retrieved from https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/calgarys-in-your-face-neo-nazis-take-to-the-streets/article573162/