Categories
Adversity Quotient Podcast

Episode 2: The Effects of COVID-19 on African Security with Zain Verjee

In this episode of Adversity Quotient, Guest speaker Zain Verjee and Sam Thiak discuss the security and economic implications of the COVID-19 pandemic on the African continent.

5 Key Points:

1. African governments are facing a health and economic crisis during the COVID-19 pandemic.

2. Gathering unified support to help African countries during COVID-19 may be more difficult than it was for the Ebola crisis due to the global nature of COVID-19.

3. Social distancing efforts in many African cities may also be difficult to achieve, particularly in slums. Furthermore, as many individuals living in the area already have compromised immune systems from other diseases and limited access to healthcare, this may put them in a more vulnerable position to be affected by the pandemic.

4. Food shortages are an area of grave concern for the African continent due to Increased locust swarms and COVID-19 border closures.

5. The COVID-19 pandemic came at a time of steady economic growth in African countries, and although this event could result in an economic recession, as it has in other areas of the world, the long term outcomes are likely to depend on international cooperation. 

About Zain Verjee:

Zain Verjee, originally from Kenya, has led an extensive career covering news stories from around the world. Former CNN anchor and CEO of the ZainVerjee Group, Zain is a highly respected and recognized journalist, with an action-packed background and experience as a storyteller and entrepreneur. Appearing on CNN USA to offer international news analysis, Zain has travelled with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to more than a dozen countries to cover numerous breaking news and world events, such as the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the Arab Spring.

Zain has worked with organizations and entities such as Bloomberg Media & Philanthropies, Equity Group Foundation of Kenya, World Health Organization, GE Africa, and the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa, interviewing international world leaders and some of the most influential men and women of our time. Zain guest hosts Africa Voices and Inside Africa feature programs, showcasing the most innovative and best of Africa.

Follow Zain on Twitter: @Zain_Verjee

Relevant Articles:

Baskar, P. (June 14, 2020). Locusts Are A Plague Of Biblical Scope In 2020. Why? And … What Are They Exactly? NPR. Retrieved from: https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/14/876002404/locusts-are-a-plague-of-biblical-scope-in-2020-why-and-what-are-they-exactly

Columbo, E. Harris, M. (May 1, 2020). Extremist Groups Stepping up Operations during the Covid-19 Outbreak in Sub-Saharan Africa.  Center for Strategic and International Studies. Retrieved from: https://www.csis.org/analysis/extremist-groups-stepping-operations-during-covid-19-outbreak-sub-saharan-africa 

Economic Commission for Africa (April 2020). COVID-19 in Africa: Protecting Lives and Economies. Retrieved from: https://www.uneca.org/sites/default/files/PublicationFiles/eca_covid_report_en_24apr_web1.pdf

Transcript:

Host Sarah Meyers (0:01): Welcome to Adversity Quotient, where we champion critical thinking, resilience and adaptability. Adversity quotient is a collaboration between the Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies, i.e. CASIS Vancouver, and the Canadian Centre for Identity-Based Conflict CCIBC, and aq IQ. Through this podcast, regular webinars and lectures with experts from around the world, the CASIS team continues to bring together exciting speakers to discuss matters of security and security-related research. My name is Sarah Myers and I will be your host for Episode Two of the Adversity Quotient. With the COVID-19 pandemic continuing to lock down a large portion of the population, countries around the world are struggling with how to manage the new demands placed on society. As a diverse place with many different cultures, traditions, and peoples, the African continent continues to see a changing shift in security concerns including essential resource scarcity, weakening healthcare infrastructure capabilities, and institutional distrust. Joining us today is former CNN anchor and head of Zain Verjee group, Zain Verjee. Originally from Kenya, Zain has led an extensive career covering news stories from around the world. As a highly respected and recognized journalist with an action-packed background and experience as a storyteller and entrepreneur, Zain has worked with organizations and entities such as Bloomberg media and philanthropies, Equity Group Foundation of Kenya, World Health Organization, GE Africa, and the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa. Zain has interviewed international world leaders and some of the most influential men and women of our time. She guest hosts Africa voices, and inside Africa feature programs showcasing the most innovative and best of Africa. She appears on CNN USA to offer international news analysis. She traveled with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice for more than a dozen countries and has covered numerous breaking news and world events, such as the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and the Arab Spring. We are also pleased to welcome our guest interviewer Sam Thea. Sam is an international relations master student at Simon Fraser University. Sam has also been a longtime CASIS Vancouver executive and has always had a focus on defense and security issues. Sam developed a passion for international relations in 2013, which was reinforced during his time at the NATO field school. And with that, I will hand it over to our interviewer and guest speaker to discuss the topic of the day: security on the African continent and what a post-COVID Africa might look like.

Sam Thiak (3:13): Hi, Zain. As you’ve heard, my name is Samuel, short name – Sam. I must say that I am lucky and excited to be on this podcast with you to ask you these questions regarding COVID-19 in Africa. I am also excited to know that you were from Kenya, a country I have lived in for over 15 years. I went to school in Kenya and although I am not originally from Kenya – I am from South Sudan – but my experiences in Kenya, I am not any less than a Kenyan. So I am really happy to have you on this podcast, and I am privileged to ask you these questions. 

Zain Verjee (4:03): Thank you.

Sam Thiak (4:04): As we mentioned earlier, this is just going to be more conversational. This is not a closed-ended question. So you will give us more information as we ask these questions. And without wasting my time, I think I should start with my first question, which is how are African governments responding to the pandemic and we’ve seen lockdowns in some countries, especially the very first countries that were hit hard, Egypt, South Africa, and then later on or these other countries join in, and the techniques they have adapted to respond to the pandemic.

Zain Verjee (4:54): Thank you so much. I should say Asante Sana, Sam for having me on your podcast, it’s such a pleasure. I am only sad that it’s in a very challenging global context and potentially very dire scenario for Africa. The African governments are in a bit of a bind because their main consideration is how do they balance public health responses and the risk of economic collapse? So you have seen across the board, multiple ways of responding, there’s not been one uniform response because this is the core consideration. In Rwanda and South Africa, for example, we’ve seen full lockdowns. In Kenya, and some other countries on the continent, you see curfews, social distancing measures, mandatory mosques and public thermal checks, schools are closed, but some businesses are open. Many countries are deploying health agents’ surveillance across their regions. So people are handling this in different ways on the continent and leaders are very nervous and very challenged because, right now, they know that the health system cannot take what we’ve been seeing around the world. There will be an utter collapse in every country where they to be overloaded the way that we’ve been seeing in, for example, Italy or the United States. So the focus for leaders is on prevention right now, that having been said, they need money and everybody in the world is having the same problem. So they’re in a scenario where it’s unlike Ebola, where they said: Hey, this is a terrible thing that’s happening, we need the financial support. And then the world came to the support because that was a potential global health issue, and an important infectious disease to ensure that there was no spread. But here everybody is fighting the same battle. So there are mechanisms that are being discussed globally amongst leaders on how do we support Africa in this crisis? So that’s a snapshot of some of the challenges that leaders are facing. 

Sam Thiak (7:12): Right. Thank you for that insightful response. And I’ll go to my second question. This very first question has been fully answered well, and the second question is basically focusing on whether the continent can handle the pandemic, as you’ve just mentioned, Africa is not new to pandemics. We’ve had Ebola before and we’ve had other diseases such as malaria. We’ve had HIV pandemics and all of that. And so you will think Africa as a continent, has the tools and the means to deal with the pandemics. So, this question is more on the strength of the leaders and the institution than the infrastructure. Do you think the strength of the leaders, the institutions, and infrastructure or even the communities, that might help the continent, weather this pandemic? Do you think this continent can weather this pandemic?

Zain Verjee (8:25): I think that there is a very serious threat of whether it can weather the pandemic or not. Again, it comes to can we prevent the spread stage here. If the best-case scenario, from what I’ve heard, you’re looking at 300,000 deaths in the continent. Worst-case scenario, 3.3 million Africans could lose their lives, depending on the measures that are taken now. So let’s look at the context a bit when it comes to institutions, and infrastructure, and communities, and what the leaders are really dealing with. The first part of the problem is the layout in different cities around the continent. Do you know, you’ve seen Nairobi, right, Sam? You know the Kibera mother and all the slums, right? And in the cities. You have many African cities in the same kind of urban slum scenario, some of the biggest on the continent also, in South Africa and Nigeria. So the majority of our populations live in overcrowded neighbourhoods with high population densities, no reliable access to clean water, poor sanitation. Something a conversation about hospital beds does not even exist in some of these environments. It is impossible to talk about social distancing and isolation in slum areas like this. And as you yourself alluded to, the immunities of many of the people that live here are also quite compromised. They’ve had to deal with HIV, Tuberculosis, Malaria, as you said, and now COVID-19, these are the scenarios in which the governments have to operate, where the health systems institutionally are very weak. ICU’s, beds, ventilators, in some instances in Africa, there are more cabinet ministers in a country than ventilators. So Kenya itself has 300 ventilators, right? You know, the population of Kenya is millions. So what do you, how do you deal with a scenario like this, and lastly, you will also appreciate that we are mostly informal sector workers on the continent. We are juasi cali. We work out in the open air is the literal translation. So what do you earn that day, you eat. Now if you enforce a lockdown, you are going to have starvation. You’re going to have millions of people saying: wow, we know you want to do social distancing but how are we going to put food on the table? We have to work. So are the very serious concerns that African leaders are grappling with both institutional and otherwise. And by the way, there’s no bailout. Right here you’re seeing trillions of dollars in bailout packages in Europe and the United States. We can’t do that. We just can’t. We can’t do that in our countries and send this kind of money into people’s wallets directly. It’s very challenging.

Sam Thiak (11:29): That’s absolutely right. And you’ve just mentioned how the lockdown affects a lot of people who rely on the day-to-day work. Like juasi cali or hauking in the city selling stuff to get, you know, a few shillings to survive the day. So if you lock down these people, how are they going to survive? And I’ve heard as well with some relatives back there, and some friends in Kenya who are honestly saying: You know, I would rather die of COVID-19 on the street than die of hunger while in my house, or my kids, you know, who will not get anything to eat. And so it is a really hard situation for a lot of people.

Zain Verjee (12:14): And to that point, Sam, the hunger issue is doubly compounded because number one, you have border closures, so flights aren’t coming in. So, therefore, we’re not getting the food imports that we need. So Africa is heavily dependent on food imports. So that’s not coming in the ports, not on flights. And number two, there is a locust crisis in eastern Africa, multiple people are facing waves of locusts. This one today is now 20 times the size it was early in the year. It’s the long rains [season] right now. And they’re laying eggs that are going to create local swarms, 20 more times bigger, and that is extraordinary to even wrap your head around because, if you think of it, one swarm of locusts, just one, Sam. One swarm is a third of a mile, ok? One swarm can eat food for 35,000 people. Now you think about that. That is the food crisis that is looming.

Sam Thiak (13:24): That’s true. That’s true. Now that you mentioned the locust problem, which started just before the COVID-19 became mainstream, locust was already there. It was crossing borders. It was, you know, moving from one area to another across Africa. And so that’s a real concern indeed. But yeah, I will move to the next question which will address, obviously, the main thing that Africa has been known for – the conflicts and conflicts. And that is we have a lot of armed groups on African continent born from terrorist organizations like Boko Haram and Al Shabaab to just civil wars, just like in South Sudan. So do you think well-armed groups feel the administrative gaps where national governments are absent during the crisis? And if so, will this increase their legitimacy?

Zain Verjee (14:31): I think that is a very good question. And that is quite possible. From security experts I’ve talked to on the ground, they do think that that could happen much like, you see, you know, in conflict zones, these armed groups can emerge and provide very powerful and important social services, and thereby increase their legitimacy. So I think that is a danger and a potential that national governments are aware of, but they’re distracted with COVID right now. There are other ways that terrorist terror groups are taking advantage. You have ISIS and Al Qaeda working together in the cell taking over large swaths of West Africa, Nigeria, Chad, Al Shabaab, as you know, in East Africa, Boko Haram in Nigeria, so they are all wanting to further their terrorist agendas and filling administrative gaps where national governments are not there is definitely a vacuum that they may fill.

Sam Thiak (15:32): Right. That’s absolutely right. I think that response is quite clear for that question, and I will, for the sake of our time, move to the next question. You’ve addressed the response of the governments and the leaders on the African continent but we have an organization, the African Union, and its various roles. What has been the response from the African Union, where the countries work together more or where people are linked to armed groups for leadership that, of course, it relates to the other question of armed groups on the continent. And maybe we can just add a little bit of other foundation, like the Jack Ma foundation. We’ve seen Jack Ma send equipment to deal with this outbreak in various African continent, sorry, various African countries. So how do you see the response of the African Union and other partners like Jack Ma foundation?

Zain Verjee (16:42): The African Union, whose meetings I’ve attended a few times, had made silencing the guns a major campaign and a major priority for 2020 onwards and then got hit by Coronavirus. So while the importance of that is still there, ending the armed conflict, child soldiers, impact on women and girls, and economics, the resources that were earmarked to fight extremist groups have been diverted to humanitarian efforts. So governments have their hands full with COVID and the fears of food shortages, etc. And so there is a fear that there will be off the guns. Where with respect to your question about working together with partners? Yes. Jack Ma has been amazing. And Jack Ma has brought in supplies that Africa needs and that the whole world has been fighting for, and left Africa at the bottom of the list. So having someone like Jack Ma to come and do that has been really appreciated. The African leaders have had partners globally, but those same partners are in their own dire straits. So I think it is a very big challenge. The finance ministers of the continent are one body that have come together to essentially go to international lending organizations and say: listen, we need a bailout. We need a $100 billion debt standstill, which is the core of the topic right now. So actually, it’s not a bailout. It’s essentially saying, we know we owe you money. We know we will have to pay back debt, the principal as well as interest, but can everybody just hold everything for now, so we don’t have to pay you $44 billion because we have that liquid cash in the bank waiting to pay you. So if you could just pause for a minute, we can take that money and we can use it for the COVID crisis. But they are asking for an additional $66 billion for this year, and probably more next year, in some kind of liquidity form. That is new money that they can use to fight Coronavirus so the armed groups and the struggles that we have with them are actually, unfortunately, quite at the back burner right now.

Sam Thiak (19:15): Okay, thank you for that. And the 2014-2016 current, sorry, Ebola outbreak in the west of Africa was one of the major pandemics. How would you compare that outbreak of 2014 and 2016 to the current situation? Obviously, we know, mostly, a lot of people, did not know that was most of West Africa that was affected by the outbreak. It was contained mostly there and it did not spread even to other parts of Africa, let alone to the rest of the world. So how would you compare that Ebola outbreak to the current situation?

Zain Verjee (20:00): Obviously, this is a pandemic and that was contained. So that’s the first piece. The second is that with the Ebola outbreak, at the time, certain procedures and systems started coming into place in West Africa and even other countries on the continent. So the surveillance at airports, the temperature checks, the health workers being deployed to multiple places to quarantine and isolate those that they needed to. To really try and understand the disease and research to communicate effectively with citizens. One area of important learning was how religious communities were actually causes and vehicles in which the disease would spread because they would have religious rituals or burial rituals, and the disease would spread. So quite quickly, any kind of religious gathering was banned right away on the continent for Coronavirus. So educating the public is vital communication to young populations during the time of Ebola was vital. Curfews and stopping movement of people was important. So all of these things we learned how to do during the Ebola crisis. So there are systems of an emergency like this there were in place in African countries, and we were able to execute them. But we haven’t seen anything on a scale like this, which is what is scary.

Sam Thiak (21:27): That’s absolutely right. The last question, and that leadership section is, is basically a prediction on how Africa would emerge from the pandemic. As you know, those are hard questions, even here in the West, where governments have advanced statistical models to make predictions. It is never always, it is sometimes you get to miss out. So is it possible to make a prediction on how Africa will emerge from the pandemic?

Zain Verjee (21:57): I think pretty badly it’s going to be tough. The African economies for the last decade have been growing. They’ve been growing by, and as was proven predicted this year, by 3.2% GDP growth. Now you will see economies that are projected to shrink in totality on the continent by 1.6%. So there is going to be a long and tough recovery process. And hopefully we’ll see a stronger future investment into health systems and an understanding that we have to have a greater need for self reliance. If you look at just our current economic hit, it will tell you what the recovery has to look like. You have a 48% decline in employment, you have 51% of exports have basically dried up, if not more, at this point. Supply chains have been hit, remittances are down. Nigeria who relies on a $65 billion exports of oil a year is now going to experience an excruciating loss. Their budget, everybody’s budgets have blown up. Air travel and transport, tourism, the farmer industries, everything has come to a standstill. Infrastructure, ports, roads, any investment into health systems, it’s all stopped. So the recovery to that and the industries that surround it, like tourism. You’ve been to the lodges in Mara, you have been to the coast. You know how much tourism drives Kenya. And I’m telling you, every hotel is shut. Maybe there’s three or four rooms in the hotels that are open. Everybody’s laid off, the chefs, the hostesses, the waitresses, the hotel staff, like everyone that drive us, the gods. So we look at that, like look at that recovery that needs to happen.

Sam Thiak (23:51): That is a lot indeed. There is a lot. We are almost out of time unfortunately. I would love to keep asking you questions, as you know, it’s very interesting to hear your perspective, especially given the knowledge that you have on the African continent. And how a lot of young people, like myself, have been watching you on CNN and reporting on Africa, African voices that are rarely heard properly. And I must end with my last question to our listeners about the Coronavirus in Africa. What three key points can you leave our listeners with both locally and internationally?

Zain Verjee (24:42): Thank you. I want to say, first of all, that in Africa when we asking for money to help us right now, $100 billion dollars. I don’t want people to see this as charity or goodwill. This is about money and support to give us space to not collapse. Coronavirus is not Africa’s fault. Coronavirus was an external shock to the continent, started in Wu Han and the virus at its beginning, and I was tracking it closely, was coming in by Europeans, by foreigners or by Italians and others, travelers coming into Africa. For the last 10 years, Africa’s economic growth has been powerful. Eight of the 10 fastest growing countries in the world have been in Africa. So I envision Africa will have its first recession, in something like 25 years, where oil prices are coming down, commodity prices are down, remittances are down, tourism is down, currencies down, food prices are going up. And none of that was because of Africa. It was because of things that were happening outside of Africa. And it’s affecting us, like it’s affecting everyone else. So I would want people to look and think about Africa, that we are not beggars, and we have pulled ourselves up and operating out of quite a dignified successful space. And unfortunately, Coronavirus has created an environment and a potential danger of pulling us back decades, unfortunately. The other points I would like to make is that women and girls are at the center of this, in Africa and globally. I don’t want women and girls to be thought of Oh, and what about women and girls? 70% of global health workers on the front lines are women. Those women come home, they have families, they need to cook, sometimes women, they’re exposed to disease and now they are the breadwinners as well. You are in scenarios too where women are at home, often trapped now with their abusers. So they’re being beaten, violence is rising. Kids are out of school. 188 million African children are out of school, right? They’re sitting at home. They need protection, they need education, they need to eat. Now the mothers are expected to handle that as well. The mental health cost is huge. So and last point, you know, you gave me three so that’s the problem with telling someone numbers you have. I just want to say if one of us has the virus, all of us have it. So it’s in the world’s interests to support Africa and to make sure that given our weak systems, and we’re all very smart people and Africans have African solutions and we are helping ourselves even now. We are digging our own pockets and we are looking for innovative ways to get testing, and turn factories into manufacturing masks and shields, and all sorts of things. So if we don’t calm back Coronavirus in Africa, it will find its way back to the west.

Sam Thiak (28:05): Thank you very much for the amazing insight you’ve given us, Zain. I must mention to you that, you know, your first name is Zain and when I was in high school, in Kenya, I was also called Zain.

Zain Verjee (28:18): Oh, how did you become Sam?

Sam Thiak (28:21): I became Sam when I came here but…

Zain Verjee (28:24): Oh, no, no, no, we call you Zain now.

Sam Thiak (28:29): It was a nickname given to me in high school, you know, when Zain before safari come Kim

Zain Verjee (28:35): Yes,of course. I loved it. That is my name everywhere.

Sam Thiak (28:39): Yes, yeah. But yeah, I really appreciate your time. I’m really glad and excited to have had this opportunity with you. Thank you very much.

Zain Verjee (28:47): Very welcome, Sam. It’s my pleasure.

Host Sarah Meyers (28:49): Thank you so much for that. Okay, so as a conclusion, I’d like to close off Episode Two of the podcast with a big thank you to our guests Zain Verjee and Sam Thiak for your discussion and your insights. Also, thank you to the production team, Evan Pierce, Asmaa Patel and David Henningman who worked behind the scenes to make all of this happen. This has been the second episode of the Adversity Quotient podcast. We will continue to release new episodes every Monday with exciting guest speakers keeping you informed of the unfolding security environment. Thank you for listening and we will see you next Monday.

New episodes of Adversity Quotient are available every Monday! Follow @CASISVancouver for the latest news and updates.


Disclaimer: Views expressed are those of the speakers and do not necessarily represent those of CASIS Vancouver or any of its partners. Information given is not verified by CASIS or any third party acting on its behalf