By Anonymous
In an increasingly digitized world, privacy is a constant concern. Since governments are turning to contact tracing applications (apps), such as ABTraceTogether in Alberta, as a new development to monitor the spread of COVID-19, the privacy of individuals has been pushed to the forefront of the conversation (MacKinnon, 2020; Wells, 2020). Moreover, it has raised the question of whether or not the privacy of individuals should outweigh the health of the community.
What are Tracing Apps?
These apps use bluetooth technology to track individuals and identify when they have come into contact with someone with COVID-19 (Wells, 2020). Alberta is the first province in Canada to launch an app to help with contact tracing during the pandemic (Wells, 2020). If such contact has occurred, the app notifies the user to suggest beginning the necessary self-isolation procedures (Wells, 2020). One of the concerns with using bluetooth technology instead of GPS is that bluetooth can turn off as a battery saving function (Nellis & Dave, 2020). With the potential for the app to turn off on its own (i.e. with using bluetooth only), there is the possibility that it could miss interactions where the app user might have come in contact with the virus (Nellis & Dave, 2020).
What are the Main Concerns with Privacy Anyway?
While many are concerned about the rise of the surveillance state in general, the main concern is this data getting hacked or leaked to the general public. However, within Canada, the privacy commissioner has stated that the government must obtain meaningful consent from citizens if they choose to use tracking apps (Boynton, 2020). If the information surrounding who has been infected is leaked, there is the potential for the businesses that were visited by individuals who might be infected to be boycotted (Nellis & Dave, 2020). Given that many small and medium sized businesses are at a greater risk of closing during this time, any avoidance by the public due to an information leak would be detrimental to these businesses.
Privacy By Design
Since 2010, there has been an widely accepted approach when engineering apps or other technologies that use personal information called Privacy by Design (Cavoukian, n.d.). This approach states that privacy must be considered in every step of the process so that it becomes integral to the function of the design rather than an afterthought (Cavoukian, n.d.). There are several Privacy by Design considerations when developing apps for COVID-19 that should be at the forefront of the conversation. These include: defining a clear and limited purpose for the collection, use, and storage of the data, limiting the collection, retention, and analysis of the data, and being transparent by providing clear instructions in plain language (Harel, 2020).
Is There a Need to be Worried About Privacy?
The Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPCC) has put out a statement that privacy laws are still in place during a public health crisis, however, they are not a barrier to information sharing (Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, 2020). The provincial governments are also able to declare their own emergencies, which can potentially expand their ability to collect and use personal information (Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, 2020). There is legislation in place to protect the privacy of individuals, such as the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA), which applies to private sector organizations. Additionally, there is the Privacy Act which applies to the federal government. Within each of these provisions there are exemptions through which the government can require organizations and departments to provide personal information during emergencies and crises.
Overall, the OPCC has made several comments that there needs to be adequate consent from Canadian citizens if a national approach using apps is to be taken. In order to better protect this information, it should stay on the user’s phone and remain unidentified and aggregate data (Boynton, 2020). Further requirements include the information only be kept for a limited time, and once the pandemic is over, that the data be destroyed (Boynton, 2020). Additionally, one could assume that since the Privacy by Design approach has been widely accepted by the International Association of Privacy Professionals, that it would be heavily considered in the development of COVID-19 related apps. However, given the urgency required to develop these apps, it is important that the developers are transparent in their goals and their use of people’s personal information.
While there is always a risk when it comes to privacy and apps, the OPCC seems to have outlined the privacy concerns that need to be addressed in order to ensure the best safety and security of Canadians’ data.
Sources:
Boynton, S. (May 3rd, 2020). Consent for coronavirus tracing apps must be ‘meaningful’, Canada’s privacy watchdog says. Global News. Retrieved from https://globalnews.ca/news/6896631/coronavirus-canada-contact-tracing-privacy/
MacKinnon, B. (May 7th, 2020). Canada’s privacy commissioners offer guidance on COVID-19 contact-tracing apps. CBC News. Retrieved from https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/covid-19-contact-tracing-app-privacy-commissioners-new-brunswick-1.5557548
Nellis, S., Dave, P. (May 5th, 2020). Coronavirus: Apple, Google to ban location tracking in joint contact tracing system. Global News. Retrieved from https://globalnews.ca/news/6905439/google-apple-contact-tracing-location/
Wells, N. (May 2nd, 2020). ‘Invasion of privacy’: Watchdogs concerned about apps tracking COVID-19 patients. Global News. Retrieved from https://www.ctvnews.ca/sci-tech/invasion-of-privacy-watchdogs-concerned-about-apps-tracking-covid-19-patients-1.4921995
Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (March, 2020). Privacy and the COVID-19 outbreak. Government of Canada. Retrieved from https://www.priv.gc.ca/en/privacy-topics/health-genetic-and-other-body-information/health-emergencies/gd_covid_202003/
Disclaimer: Insights (including any that may have been created by executives or employees of CASIS, CCIBC, or AQ-IQ) are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the opinions, beliefs or viewpoints of CASIS, CCIBC, or AQ-IQ.
