By Davina Shanti
In response to COVID-19 gangs, cartels, and organized crime groups (OCGs) have stepped in to fill the role of the government and provide services to citizens. These groups have provided aid packages, enforced curfews, and organized health teams to assist in fighting the virus (Sieff, Greorge, & Fahim, 2020). It can be argued that this is not the first time that criminal enterprises have had to fill the role of the government. Yet, a health crisis such as the coronavirus, may arguably provide a space for these groups to step in where government and law enforcement has been absent (Sieff et al., 2020).
What is Social Disorganization and How Can it Influence the Fight Against COVID-19
Shaw and McKay’s theory of social disorganization proposed a framework to explain why certain neighbourhoods are more prone to high crime rates (Tibbetts & Hemmens, 2019, p. 293). Factors such as poverty, cultural heterogeneity, physical dilapidation, high mobility of residents, high unemployment rates, and social ills, such as a high rate of disease, can lead to the breakdown of social organization. Arguably, a state of social disorganization leads to high rates of crime and delinquency (Tibbetts & Hemmens, 2019, p. 294). The breakdown of formal social controls creates the disorganization, evidently gangs and organized crime groups step in to provide a system of organization where neighbourhood residents, schools, social services, law enforcement, and the government cannot (Tibbetts & Hemmens, 2019, p. 295; Carlie, 2002).
In the present day, communities who experience all the factors that contribute to social disorganization arguably face more challenges to slow and prevent the spread of the virus. Such communities may lack the tools and basic healthcare requirements to effectively fight off the virus due to lack of support and aid from government authorities. Communities who experience all the factors that contribute to social disorganization may lack the tools and basic healthcare requirements to effectively fight off the virus. In situations where the government is not providing the help and support needed to members of disadvantaged communities, gangs and OCGs appear to be responsible and accountable for filling in the gap (Fajardo, 2020; Sieff, 2020). In Mexico, drug cartels, such as the Jalisco New Generation Cartel, the Gulf Cartel, and Los Viagras have been handing out aid packages and food to hundreds of people (Fajardo, 2020; Sieff, 2020). Cape Town gangs, the Americans and the Hard Livings gang worked together to distribute food to families who were financially struggling during the lockdown (Imray, 2020). Italian mafia groups in Italy may provide loans to those who are struggling economically in order to undermine the government (Sieff, 2020). In Brazil’s favelas, OCG’s have implemented curfews to control the spread of the virus and threaten those who do not abide by these rules. Similarly, in El Salvador MS-13 implemented their own curfew in the areas under their control (Sieff, 2020). These measures may be in place to protect the community, but OCG members as well.
In areas where gangs and OCGs have more influence than law enforcement, it is likely that they will naturally take on the role of the provider, protector, and enforcer. They attempt to win over local communities by providing care packages, food, and financial aid to areas that have had very little or no help from the government (Fajardo, 2020). These groups take advantage of socio-economically disadvantaged neighbourhoods by providing material goods and offering safety to maintain or gain control. However, because individuals living in such conditions have nowhere else to turn for help, they must rely on these groups (Seiff, 2020). When formal social controls during a healthcare crisis, such as COVID-19, lack presence and positive influence, disadvantaged communities may become more disorganized enabling gangs and OCGs to increase their presence and dominance. Unfortunately, in many poor neighbourhoods the state may hold very little authority and can often be absent, so residents must cope with criminal groups holding the majority of the power (Fajardo, 2020).
Future Challenges for Law Enforcement
Arguably, once the pandemic is over law enforcement may face a greater challenge of policing gangs and OCGs, and the communities in which they reside. Residents may come to accept and arguably even trust these groups because of the significant role they played in helping the community during COVID-19 (Carlie, 2002). Acceptance and trust of criminal groups increases where trust in the government and law enforcement lacks. Mistrust in formal social control may influence how residents perceive criminal groups, creating a stronger divide between law enforcement and community residents. Groups may continue to exploit weak government responses in a post-COVID-19 environment. Economic dislocation may provide criminal groups the opportunity to recruit new members by influencing public opinion and gaining support through their good deeds (Seiff, 2020). This may further enable gangs and OCGs to control certain areas and push away the influence of law enforcement.
Sources:
Carlie, M.K. (2002). Chapter 8: Neighbourhoods and Communities. In Into the Abyss: A Personal Journey into the World of Street Gangs. [eBook edition]. Retrieved from http://people.missouristate.edu/MichaelCarlie/what_I_learned_about/neighborhoods.htm
Fajardo, L. (2020, April 22). Coronavirus: Latin American crime gangs adapt to pandemic. BBC. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-52367898
Imray, G. (2020, May 18). Gang members team up to deliver food, supplies to the poor in Cape Town amid the coronavirus pandemic. Insider. Retrieved from https://www.insider.com/gang-members-deliver-food-supplies-poor-neighborhoods-in-cape-town-2020-5
Sieff, K., George, S., Fahim, K. (2020, April 14). Now joining the fight against coronavirus: The world’s armed rebels, drug cartels and gangs. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/coronavirus-taliban-ms-13-drug-cartels-gangs/2020/04/13/83aa07ac-79c2-11ea-a311-adb1344719a9_story.html?utm_campaign=wp_main&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook
Tibbetts, S.G. & Hemmens, C. (2019). The Chicago School and Cultural and Subcultural Theories of Crime. In Criminological Theory (3rd ed., pp. 287-399). SAGE Publications.
Disclaimer: Insights (including any that may have been created by executives or employees of CASIS, CCIBC, or AQ-IQ) are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the opinions, beliefs or viewpoints of CASIS, CCIBC, or AQ-IQ.
