And What It Means for the Future of Financial Institutions, the Capitalist System, and Cyber Security
By Isabella Sarria and Stephanie Wintrup
For the past year, traditional hedge fund institutions have been betting against the GameStop stock (short-selling/shorting), in turn driving the stock’s price down to an all-time low of $5 per share (CBC News, 2021). The stock price soared to a record high of $469 USD when a group of Reddit inspired investors supposedly came to a joint decision of betting that the stock would go up. These novice investors, in what many are calling unprecedented market manipulation, arguably caused countless hedge fund managers and brokers to face massive losses, incidentally taking out two of the largest institutional investors: Citron Capital and Melvin Capital (Nagarajan & Robertson, 2021). This pivotal moment in the financial sector has called into question how this incident of mass amateur investment might be construed as an attack on traditional capitalist infrastructure, and how this might pose a threat to the stability of the stock market and national security as a whole.
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has arguably caused a surge of internet activity on behalf of Millennials (born between the years of 1981-1996) and Generation Z (born between the years of 1997-2012) (Gen Z), leading them to be more hyper-connected than ever (Sehijpaul, 2020). Gen Z’s unparalleled digital knowledge in “collecting and cross-referencing many sources of information and integrating virtual and offline experiences” has arguably made coordinating such an attack effortless (Francis & Hoefel, 2018, para. 1). This is possibly a direct result of their growing up in a fast-paced world shaped by instability and social change. With many searching to make a quick buck or simply looking to join a new movement, many Gen Zs flocked to the world of investing and trading, soaking up as much knowledge as they could from online sources — such as TikTok influencers Charles Schwab — and various accounts that reference Vanguard mutual funds training techniques; those, in turn, market their trading platforms as making stocks accessible for everyone (Kelly, 2021). A training manual soon emerged and presented an opportunity for novice and investment junkies alike to collaborate with each other, using outlets such as Discord, TikTok, Twitter, and Reddit (Kelly, 2021).
This market manipulation calls into question the systemic risk that might take over if anyone with a smartphone can join this revolt against Wall Street and traditional capitalist infrastructures and institutions. Generally, when one thinks of cybercrime in finance, all thoughts go to the three main breaches: insider trading, dissemination of false financial information, and price manipulation (Neyret, 2021). This arguably purposeful manipulation by users, primarily amateurs deciding how they want the market to play, differs from the breaches above as it is not illegal hacking or false dissemination of information, though this manipulation of the market is still likely to impact the entire chain of the financial market (Neyret, 2021).
For many, the goal was to make stockbrokers and hedge funds suffer a significant financial loss as a form of retaliation against elitist society (Silverman, 2021). Others, however, may have had more malicious intent, aiming to attack capitalist infrastructures by bringing down economic institutions. Regardless of intent, the resulting impact has arguably left the economy susceptible to security threats. The ability of individual amateur investors to facilitate such a movement through Reddit forums and various social media platforms has been broadcast across news outlets and the internet, making this economic vulnerability accessible to actors around the world, and might possibly inspire similar activities in the future.
There is no doubt that the relationship between citizens and their institutions, both political and economic, is subject to change. There are many questions that warrant attention in this increasingly tumultuous economic landscape. Some that come to mind include: What precedent does this GameStop incident set for the stock market? What role do political institutions have in regulating who can participate in stock market investments? What impact might any regulation of amatuer trading have on institutional trust? Can this be prevented in the future with stricter policies or regulations? If such regulations are imposed on who can access the stock market, how might that impact the existing economic disparity in society?
References:
Evans, P. (2021). Here’s how a Reddit group of DIY investors broke the stock market this week. CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/reddit-gamestop-blackberry-1.5890039
Francis, T., & Hoefel, F. (2018. November, 12). ‘True Gen’: Generation Z and its implications for companies. McKinsey&Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/consumer-packaged-goods/our-insights/true-gen-generation-z-and-its-implications-for-companies
Kelly, J. (2021, January 25). Freewheeling millennials and Gen-Zers are starting a new side-hustle career: aggressively trading stocks online, minting money and showing up the Wall Street pros. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2021/01/25/freewheeling-millennials-and-gen-zers-are-starting-a-new-side-hustle-career-aggressively-trading-stocks-online-minting-money-and-showing-up-the-wall-street-pros/?sh=1f11088b7b9e
Nagarajan, S., & Robertson, H. (2021, January 28). These hedge funds have got torched by the Wall Street bets army that targeted their short positions in GameStop. Business Insider. https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/hedge-funds-torched-wall-street-bets-gamestop-short-squeeze-reddit-2021-1-1030016596
Neyret. (2020). Study – Stock market cybercrime : Definition, cases and perspectives. https://www.amf-france.org/en/news-publications/publications/reports-research-and-analysis/study-stock-market-cybercrime-definition-cases-and-perspectives
Sehijpaul, P. (2020, Jun 29). Insight: Generation Z & COVID-19. CASIS Vancouver. https://casisvancouver.ca/2020/06/29/generation-z-covid-19/
Silverman, J. (2021, January 27). The game stop saga shows how casino capitalism is eating the world. The New Republic. https://newrepublic.com/article/161082/gamestop-saga-shows-casino-capitalism-eating-world
