There has been an increase in mass shootings, but radicalization research is lacking data. Researchers need interviews to move forward.
Taylor Nelson
In the United States, as of August, there have been at least 232 mass shootings so far this year (Victor, 2021). COVID-19 or not, something must change.
Given the increase in mass shootings this year, we should hope that research related to terrorism and the causes of such mass murders would be nearing closer to identifying actionable prevention strategies. As it concerns radicalization research, this does not seem to be the case. According to research published by the National Institute of Justice (NIJ) in 2018, many of the current limitations of radicalization research, at least in some studies, include those related to missing or potentially inaccurate data. Because of these data limitations, Jensen and LaFree (2016) noted that radicalization researchers are unable to account for some potentially important causal interactions, such as the relationship between mental illness, substance abuse, and violent behavior.
To address this problem, radicalization researchers should consider interviewing mass shooters. Three reasons can be pointed out for why this may help some researchers with their data limitations and bring us closer to finally understanding the more sophisticated interactions of radicalization.
To start, there is a general lack of primary sources and other research on gun violence. For example, Dooley (2017) notes that researchers from the Center for Disease and Control Prevention (CDC), are often dissuaded to research gun violence due to laws such as the Dickey Amendment and the budget cut attached to it. Furthermore, he explains that researchers are unwilling to explore how much research they can do because it could cost them their job or additional funding cuts.
Let’s say then that we acquire these new primary sources. What will that do? According to the same research published by the NIJ, new primary sources and data help fill missing conditions in research. In fact, when current findings and knowledge about radicalization can be supplemented with those based on interviews and other primary sources, it will be possible to develop truly evidence-based risk assessment instruments and methods. Furthermore, Jensen and LaFree (2016) noted that future research efforts should focus on interviews with extremists and panel surveys of at-risk populations in order to identify these missing conditions. Jensen and LaFree (2016) state that doing so will also allow researchers to better understand the processes that “produce varying extremist outcomes” and how life-course events “alter individual pathways to or from extremism” (p. 77).
Another key factor in the mass shooting dilemma is that radicalization research has focused primarily on Jihadism. In a study published in February 2019, which assessed radicalization research from 2007-2016, Schuurman states that a great deal of radicalization research has been based on Jihadist events. He, therefore, recommends broadening the scope of radicalization research. Studying specific mass shootings and their respective mass shooters through interviews will broaden the scope of research and lead to a focus on other themes and developments within radicalization.
Most importantly, however, interviews provide a better understanding of mass murders than open-source data. For example, Gill et al. (2019) noted that “closed-source data did provide a more granular insight into aspects concerned with leakage, bystanders, and radicalizing behaviors which allowed for a deeper dive into” the extent of event-specific behaviors of interest (p. 14).
The critics of this argument might argue that there is no need for radicalization researchers to interview mass shooters since professionals are already interviewing them. Of course, there is no doubt that law enforcement officials, private investigators, and even journalists have interviewed mass shooters before (Dooley, 2017). However, Gill et al. (2019) noted that information sharing between these sources is difficult and that open-source data often lacks information. They also noted that these types of data are challenging to piece together. Referencing the news journalist above, simply publishing results of letters received from mass shooters in prison does not directly help improve our understanding of radicalization. The ones conducting the research, the ones figuring out causal interactions and temporal processes of radicalization, the ones asking the right questions, should be the ones performing the interviews.
What’s the bottom line? Researchers need to double down on interviews with mass shooters. It will take time to analyze new data and implement new recommendations and programs, but new insights from interviews can take the field one step further. Surely, there are some who will want to do more than to wait on the academics and lab-coats. If they want to get involved, they should get into contact with researchers and ask to volunteer, or they can learn about deradicalization programs and help educate others, maybe even reading radicalization research itself to gain a better insight. People always ask about the best way to stop radicalization and terrorism and the answer may be hidden in the interviews.
TAYLOR NELSON is a contributing opinion writer who covers topics in the military, terrorism, and the Middle East, is the author of “North Africa and the Making of American Psychological Warfare and Propaganda, 1942-1945.” Taylor is a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania and previously studied at the United States Military Academy at West Point.
References:
Ahmed, S. (2021, May 10). There have been, on average, 10 mass shootings in the U.S. each week this year. NPR. https://www.npr.org/2021/05/10/995380788/there-have-been-on-average-10-mass-shootings-in-the-u-s-each-week-this-year
Dooley, E. (2017, October 6). Here’s why the federal government can’t study government violence. ABC News. https://abcnews.go.com/US/federal-government-study-gun-violence/story?id=50300379
Gill, P., Corner, E., McKee, A., Hitchen, P., & Betley, P. (2019). What do closed source data tell us about lone actor terrorist behavior? A research note. Terrorism and Political Violence. https://doi.org/10.1080/09546553.2019.1668781
Jensen, M., & LaFree, G. (2016). Final report: Empirical assessment of domestic radicalization (EADR). College Park, MD: START.
Schuurman, B. (2019). Topics in terrorism research: reviewing trends and gaps, 2007-2016, critical studies on terrorism, 12 (3), 463-480. https://doi.org/10.1080/17539153.2019.1579777
Smith, A. G. (2018). Risk factors and indicators associated with radicalization to terrorism in the United States: What research sponsored by the National Institute of Justice tells us. National Institute of Justice. https://nij.ojp.gov/library/publications/risk-factors-and-indicators-associated-radicalization-terrorism-united-states
Victor, D., & Taylor, D. B. (2021, May 27). A partial list of mass shootings in the United States in 2021. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/article/mass-shootings-2021.html
