In this episode of Adversity Quotient, CASIS Vancouver President Candyce Kelshall discusses the new nature of security as we move through the ongoing COVID-19 crisis.
5 Key Points:
1. In the context of COVID-19, our new normal has been shifting in terms of personal liberties and perspectives of legitimacy. We can’t continue to do what we used to do, we should not step on the rights of others, in the pursuit of affluence but rather we should ensure that our community is itself affluent not just financially but in safety as well.
2. The way forward will require being resilient, dynamic, and adaptable as change is inevitable.
3. There is a need to focus on evidence rather than peoples’ opinions and assumptions. We should be careful when pressing “like” or sharing posts online as through doing so, we may be building communities which are based on assumptions rather than sound information.
4. In a crisis, very strong clear messaging is going to be important in order to help us proactively determine how we should move forward, otherwise there will be risk of disunity, inconsistency, or mixed messaging.
5. Our significantly more developed reliance on the Internet as a means of communication, given the recent lockdowns, means that we should stop thinking in terms of individuals being the main actors and instead, start to understand that what we’re seeing are actions energized by groups of people connected by shared ideas.
About Candyce Kelshall

Candyce Kelshall is a seasoned, in-theatre operational director and has worked extensively with militaries and advising police forces around the world as well as designing and delivering training to specialist units.
She is a former senior diplomat who is comfortable liaising with governments and operating at all levels within parliamentary and military contexts. She has taught vocational (police, law enforcement, military and intelligence) as well as academic programs in over 17 countries. She has been teaching in a university professional program context for the last 10 years.
Kelshall has extensive experience teaching both undergraduate and graduate programs in international relations, geo-strategic security, intelligence, risk & threat assessment. She has 30 years experience in diplomacy, law-enforcement and military professional training, and ten years as military and police advisor in the UK. She has previously served as a diplomat, naval officer, specialist advisor and consultant in disaster response, critical incident and terrorist response, national emergency management and multi-agency joint operations architecture, as well as training design for intelligence fusion centres. She is currently teaching at Simon Fraser University as an Adjunct Professor of Criminology. Her current research interests lie in violent transnational social movements and their role in fifth generation war, the evolving nature of contemporary conflict, post-structural perspectives on human security, and subaltern realism in developing countries.
Kelshall is currently the President of the Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies (CASIS) – Vancouver , which encourages and promotes the study and practice of intelligence and security through its research projects, instructional teams, the biannual publication of the Journal of Intelligence, conflict and Warfare, roundtable events and the annual CASIS West Coast Security Conference. She serves as Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of Intelligence, Conflict and Warfare, which publishes practitioner-focused briefing notes and articles on contemporary Canadian security issues. Kelshall is also a board member at the Canadian International Council – Vancouver, which is dedicated to advancing Canada’s place in the world. Kelshall currently serves as the Director of DA-IC, which conducts specialist training to military units and police officers.
Relevant Articles:
Bronskill, J. (2020, April 13th). COVID-19 shows national security failings intelligence expert says. Canada’s National Observer. Retrieved from https://www.nationalobserver.com/2020/04/13/news/covid-19-shows-national-security-failings-intelligence-expert-says
Gurski, P. (2020, March 30). What role for Canadian intelligence during the COVID-19 crisis? The Hill Times. Retrieved from https://www.hilltimes.com/2020/03/30/what-role-for-canadian-intelligence-during-the-covid-19-crisis/240647
O’Brien, M. (2020, May 29). Advocating Security Fundamentals During and After COVID-19. Security Intelligence. Retrieved from https://securityintelligence.com/posts/advocating-security-fundamentals-during-and-after-covid-19/
Wark, W. (2020, March). Health Intelligence, National Security and the COVID-19 Pandemic. Canadian Global Affairs Institute. Retrieved from https://www.cgai.ca/health_intelligence_national_security_and_the_covid_19_pandemic
Transcript:
Host Sarah Meyers (0:01): Welcome to Adversity Quotient where we champion critical thinking, resilience and adaptability. Adversity Quotient is a collaboration between the Canadian Association for Security and Intelligence Studies (i.e. CASIS-Vancouver), the Canadian Centre for Identity-Based Conflict (i.e. CCIBC), and AQ-IQ. In order to demonstrate our own resilience, we have moved CASIS-Vancouver’s regular events online. Through this podcast, regular webinars, and lectures with experts from around the world, we can continue our discussions on security and security-related research. My name is Sarah and I will be your host for Episode 1 of the Adversity Quotient. After weeks of lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic, a new security dynamic is emerging. From creatures to preppers, new social actors are emerging around the globe in resistance to the quarantine measures. Today we have with us Candyce Kelshall, an expert in unconventional conflict. She is here to discuss new theoretical models and techniques to analyze these shifts and how they may change the security environment as we know it. Candyce has over 30 years of military, intelligence, vocational, and diplomatic experience and has a particular passion for bringing new perspectives to ongoing conflict and security issues, such as Somali piracy. This week we are pleased to introduce CASIS guest interviewer, Natalie Archutowski. She is the Executive Officer for the Canadian Centre for Identity-Based Conflict, the co-author of several security publications, and is currently working on a structured models, approaches, and techniques textbook focusing on identity-based conflict with Candyce Kelshall. Natalie has previously published in both volumes of the CASIS Structured Analytical Techniques textbooks. And with that, we will hand over to our guest interviewer and guest speaker to discuss the topic of the day: Public Safety Reimagined: COVID-19 and the New Security Paradigm.
Natalie Archutowski (2:12): Thank you, Sarah. Thanks for having us on today. Candyce I would like to start off with my first question. What do you see as the new normal from a security perspective, particularly as we move through times that most of my generation won’t remember, as the last pandemic of the global scale happened over 100 years ago?
Candyce Kelshall (2:33): That’s a really good question and there are a couple things that I want to raise. One is that given that we are dealing with human beings in a state of connectivity in society, by our very nature things, crises, emergencies, these things are fluid, dynamic and continuous as we’re human beings and that’s part of what makes us who we are. So there will always be new problems that we have to deal with and that is why being able to be adaptable and resilient and dynamic is important. It’s part of being able to deal with being human-being in a vibrant society. So having said that, this is a crisis that we’re currently dealing with. It’s a crisis somewhat unlike any that we’ve dealt with in our living memory but it is nevertheless a crisis that involves working and operating with people in a set of parameters, that is, the space is defined by government law and order and by people who are consenting to follow those rules and those instructions. And we have to take any investigation into what security means into that space in order for us to understand how things may or may not be shifting. So the short answer is: yes, it is the new normal and the long answer is that it is a new normal but human beings by their very nature evolve and change and the nature of our societies also evolves and changes. But what is distinct now I think from the research that we’ve been doing is that we are in a sense operating in a new space and it is a space where things like personal liberties, perspectives of legitimacy are changing on a daily basis. “Who is a legitimate authority?” for example. That is a question being asked on the internet extensively, and a question, I might argue, being acted upon as we speak. Another thing that is unique to security practitioners is that idea of predictive policing based on patterns of predictive behavior. Well when you’re in a new normal, such as this situation that we are in, those patterns might actually reverse. We might see things like organized crime groups working closely with communities in order to keep people safe on lockdown and secured with food and medicine. And in fact, we have numerous examples of that happening. In Brazil for instance, where organized crimes are under the organized crime gangs in other communities are doing just that in the areas that they operate in. So one might argue that those predictive policing models may not be accurate in the new space that we find ourselves operating within and that just speaks of the dynamism and fluidity that I mentioned before that we need to have in order to be adaptable and resilient. So if you’re policing based on predictive patterns, which are based itself on trends and patterns from the past, and if you consciously policing statistics might be burdened with cognitive bias through years of looking at particular communities in a criminalised manner, or with a criminalised mindset, then we will see something very different and distinct emerging. So today, if we come back to the present as residents in our respective countries we have come to expect a certain degree of liberty, privacy, freedom, self-determination, and the importance of fighting for our rights and speaking up for those rights that’s part of our DNA as a society in the West. The question now is: whose rights are more valid? Is it a healthy society’s rights or is it an individual’s rights to all those things that I stated previously. So the question I think that we really need to ask is that what values do the new normal, what values does that bring when we are operating in such a space? And that is the issue that I think really need to grapple with. You might consider that we have to think through the possibility of actually renegotiating social contracts between what communities expect our law enforcement to provide and what we actually need in this space. And another big change that I see is that messengers are changing. Who we listen to might be beginning to change and that that’s probably quite problematic. Are we listening to science and knowledge or the loudest populist voice and it’s echo chambers? And what if those voices are part of our community? Which voice takes precedence? Knowledge and legitimacy, which forms authority, or echo chambers which are polarized and which represent acceptance, belonging and community and I think that is the key question we need to ask in terms of what is security for us in this new space and that’s one of the big things we need to grapple with, is that question of authority and legitimacy. So the other point that’s important I think is messengers and understanding that in times of crises we are changing who we listen to. We change who we listen to based on several things. Usually in a crisis, an authoritarian leader emerges. It may not be the best leadership in a peacetime environment but in crises, authoritarian leaders have better results because they’re very clear and specific and explicit about what people need to do and people respond to that in a state of instability. Now the thing to think about here is that in such a circumstance resistance is expected and normal, but there’s a bigger problem at stake and that is where that leadership does not emerge, we might see disunity or inconsistency or confused messaging coming from those who have legitimate authority to tell us what to do and how to behave in a crisis. And in such a circumstance, the evidence shows us that societies and communities turned to who they trust in order to get information. And that may not necessarily be the best course of action in an environment in which misinformation and conspiracy theories are bound. And so what we see happening is in the space of disunity, inconsistency, or confused messaging coming from those who are legitimate authority to tell us what to do and how to behave in a crisis. And in such a circumstance, the evidence shows us that societies and communities turn to who they trust in order to get information and that may not necessarily be the best course of action in an environment in which misinformation and conspiracy theories are bound. And so what we see happening is in the space of disunity, inconsistency, or confused messaging, great polarization and disorder and something that we call, discord, tends to emerge. So very strong clear messaging is going to be important in order to help us proactively determine how we should move forward. I think there’s just one other thing I’d want to add about what the new normal looks like, and that is that I think we should start thinking about groups of people being connected by shared ideas, being the main actors in the society as we move forward, and the use of technology, the Internet. Our significantly more developed reliance on the Internet as a means of communication, given the recent lockdowns means that we should stop thinking in terms of individuals being the main actors but instead, start to think and understand that what we’re seeing are groups of people connected by these shared ideas. And there’s one point that’s important to note here and that is that if you remove, jail or kill someone who has an idea, it doesn’t stop the idea. It probably makes the idea grow stronger and people tend to think as units therefore, in a shared fight or in a shared difficulty. And the one thing people want to do is to protect that unit. So, what we see emerging is a new type of dynamic which I’m not sure intelligence and policing is really taken fully into account and that’s one thing that we need to be considering clearly. Long answer, my apologies.
Natalie Archutowski (10:23): It’s alright, thank you for your insights. You mentioned that it is really important to have clear messaging in relation to ensuring that spread of misinformation is mitigated within populations. Do you see a country or a state or a region that has done a really good job of maintaining clear and consistent messaging without shifting towards that authoritarian position?
Candyce Kelshall (10:50): That is a really interesting question that you’re asking. The one question that pops to mind for me is Taiwan almost immediately. I would say Taiwan and arguably I would say Trinidad and Tobago of all the countries that I’ve been monitoring, those are two countries where there is a straight up a non political, direct, clear messaging that is emerging and the population in both those instances are responding and the statistics in terms of the infections and people’s behavior is a testament to that happening. In Taiwan’s consideration, they have previously experienced emergencies such as this one and so to some extent, they are prepared in the sense that the entire society immediately did what they knew they should be doing because they had been prepared for what should occur in such a circumstance. And I think these are lessons to be learned by looking at those 2 countries with very low infection rates and very quick recovery rates.
Natalie Archutowski (11:58): Alright, you also mentioned the technological impact and how we’ve had to change our way of operating and how we use technology to remain connected with the people that we not only work with but who are in our social circles and who we love, our friends and family. How do you see the innovation of technological capabilities as impacting the security spheres? Not just from a global security perspective, but also a national security perspective here in Canada.
Candyce Kelshall (12:35): Right, well very very broad question but again, I think the commonality lies in the fact that technology for use in public safety and security is definitively now hardwired into how we go forward into the next iteration of what safety and security looks like. Like it or not there are some new abilities which we are inheriting and which will be here to stay now. I think technology very much defines the new normal. In the past we’ve had police units and public safety units being quite resistant to introducing new technology because of the relationship that the police and public safety environment has with the public. Intrusion and insecurity are things that we used to give as reasons for not embracing more technology. I think now we might define insecurity as not using technology because we need it to help us trace, isolate, locate, and track people who either have COVID or who are recovered and have antibodies. And so, we will literally inherit these abilities that we’re developing to track and trace COVID that will become part of our DNA, if you will, within the public safety sphere after COVID. And it does mean we will have to renegotiate the social contract with society between law enforcement and governance. One of these other areas that may be impacted from a technology perspective is the question of physical continuity of evidence chains. In the past, policing and law enforcement has been very shy about using cloud based solutions and I think one thing that this pandemic is definitely shown is the joint nature of security threats and that one jurisdiction alone cannot fight something of this nature. Not unless you want to close our walls and become a fortress. So I think technology, and how we are needing technology in a new way, and using it in new ways as a result of this crisis, it means that as we move forward into the future, I’d definitely see a deeper embracing of artificial intelligence, algorithms of machine learning, big data usage, and in particular for our cause, updated data layering. Data layering is going to become imperative, where we take different sources of information in different models and layer it together to get a better understanding of what we’re dealing with. And I think blending these with traditional analysis and policing will be the key to our continuing to stay safe and defining security as we move forward. In many ways existing software just is not useful and in this new environment, one might argue that it is outdated. Particularly one based on old models looking at individual rational decision making as the reason why an individual opted to choose to go into crime. I think given this new social nature of how people will be operating, that might be one thing we want to think about. And also old policing models tend to be based on existing crime patterns and existing crime statistics and the new normal may reveal something very different.
Natalie Archutowski (16:13): That was a very comprehensive answer, you’ve answered my next question already. So let me move into another question that is pressing which is you’ve discussed the models and the environment within which security professionals work and how institutions operate. What do you see as some of the biggest challenges for the individual professionals within the security and intelligence field as we move forward? I recently read an article about some of the challenges of human and confidential informant recruiting as a result of empty public spaces, that’s one example that I can think of. So what do you see as some of those biggest challenges?
Candyce Kelshall (16:58): Well that’s an awesome example that you’re giving. Ironically, the biggest challenge to professionals as we move forward are the professionals themselves and I say that with the greatest of respect and humility, I’ve spent decades working in this space. The police, law enforcement, public safety, work hard to keep security of our environments intact and so I’m not in any way disrespecting those people who were doing hard work on our behalf, but what I’m suggesting is that might need to change and change is not something that law and law enforcement is easily accomplished. That is because of the nature of the law, it is to uphold and enforce existing patterns of behavior. How do we do that while patterns of behavior are in the process of change and environments around this are in the process of change? It takes law, it takes legal frameworks, it takes police training, a longer time to change to match those evolving norms and changing norms. So, that is possibly one of the biggest challenges that I see ahead of us. What else I think might be something that we need to take into account? Well, it sort of comes back to technology, I think. I think the role of intelligence analysts will become increasingly more important, significantly more important than previously and that is because a public safety is going to need not just the skills of people who are out doing human work and people on the frontline or police officers on the front line, but I think we need to be more intelligent about how we do that especially giving limited resources and limited funding available for more unpredictable and more unsafe spaces. And they’re unpredictable and unsafe simply because we don’t have statistics and we don’t know how things might change. And in that sense, I think using big data, again using AI algorithms to help us identify trends and patterns of change, which we may or may not be aware of, I think using models that are tailored to individual cultural nuances and patterns of normal and abnormal behavior. That’s going to help us approach safety and security in a more intelligent way, and a more necessary way, given that the old existing crime patterns may not be there; there will always be crime and there will always be opportunistic and petty crime. There will always be homicide. These things are a given, but particularly where we start looking at where people are protesting or there is disorder or there is violence, which is social and designed to to fragment some of the unity that is so important at this point in time, those things are difficult to predict or to understand, and in that sense we’re going to need to change how we do what we do. Which is why I think something like data layering would be so important for helping us to reveal and understand new types of criminality and also help us to make a safer space that does not involve victimizing certain communities based on how they behaved in the past or how we perceive they have behaved in the past. And we have to always be mindful that an enemy-centric approach to any population will create an enemy-centric response from that population and the ultimate result between those two things is group conflict and that disunity is the one thing that we do not want. So the biggest challenge, I think is embracing technology. That’s going to be important.
Natalie Archutowski (20:36): Thank you once again. I was gonna ask what skills I needed to succeed in this contemporary environment, but you’ve cleared that up really well for us, thank you. You touched on group conflict as well as civic conflict, what is that? How is it distinct from the traditional models of conflict in an understanding of communities; this is an area of research you’ve focused a lot in, so just for the benefit of our listeners, could you explain that clearly, thank you?
Candyce Kelshall (21:09): Well, what we’ve been looking at increasingly, particularly looking at the rise of extremism, we’re looking at groups like ISIS, which has occupied a fair amount of my time over the last three years or so. When we look at these groups, groups such as organisations, or let me use the correct phrasing: movements, such as white supremacy, male supremacy. When we start examining those more closely what we find happening is that we don’t have so much as groups or hierarchical structures or organizations issuing instructions and orders from the top down so that the people on the bottom go out and commit whatever is required based on instructions given to them and based on training that they have received in order to do that. What we find instead is that that type of structure is not prevalent in society today to a large extent. And “large extent,” by that I mean, within our communities. So while there are organizations that exist like that, the ones that I’ve mentioned: social movements, extremism, white supremacy, etc, those don’t operate using the same rules. and So what we found when we do that is particularly when we look at some organized crime bands we find that there are different structures in place and that helps us understand how better to mitigate dealing with them. So social movements are important for us to think about because it means we no longer think about the individual as a decision-maker in an action or the person who conducts the bombing or the person who drives a van into a group of people on a street, that isn’t an individual action. Someone who goes into a mosque and shoots a mosque. Or someone who goes into a Jewish area and murders people who are at worship. These we need to stop thinking of as lone actors or individuals with mental health issues because it simply isn’t the case. What is the case is that these individuals were part of movements. We know this by looking at things they read, at the conversations they engaged in in online open forums, the nature of the material that they kept in and around them, the types of photographs that they issued of themselves, the language that they use, the actual words that they use, are being indicative of reading certain sets of material, that’s called discourse analysis. So we now have a much deeper understanding, and particularly at CASIS, we’ve devoted several years of doing research into this area, we now understand that these social movements have a particular set of factors that help us to understand what happens to predict or be proactive about how we might approach dealing with groups like that. And so I think that the Internet dependence that the corporate situation has forced upon people has done a service on the one hand by helping people unite and on the other hand a disservice because some of the people who have been uniting and cementing relationships may not have the best interests at heart.
Natalie Archutowski (24:32): Alright, thank you.
Candyce Kelshall (24:34): A bit of a long-winded answer.
Natalie Archutowski (24:35): That’s okay, those are where we get the most insight. I appreciate it. You discussed the development of new ways of thinking and models that incorporate almost a social science understanding of the world to bringing in those theories. You have personally been working on developing structured analytical techniques that incorporate this background, how is that different from our traditional use of these tools?
Candyce Kelshall (24:36): Right, another good question. Very different. Spectacularly different. What we find in our research is that most policing and public safety software is in fact based on the premise that actors have made a rational decision-making decision, and that is a school of study where we measure individuals choices based on the risks and benefits associated with that individual making that choice and that they choose to act because the benefit is greater than the risk. What looking at social movements does is help us understand that within a particular group, making a decision, it becomes a high risk decision, becomes easier, because as a group that collective encourages that decision-making to be seen, that particular decision, to be seen as a correct decision, so in groups individual ideas tends to move towards the extreme overtime, our research has shown. And this is backed by extensive research by other authors as well, such as Moskalenko and McCauley would be one set of authors that come to mind immediately. So what we have found is within social movements the impetus to move towards violence is much quicker and much more dispersed so that we can have individuals in a movement online reading the same material having discussions about the same thoughts and that that process and action increases the likelihood that they will be a violent kinetic action offline because the cost benefit analysis becomes more focused on benefit than cost if everybody in the group is agreeing that it’s a good thing to do, then your sense of what is right or wrong becomes skewed so the individual’s role in making a decision becomes less important than the group’s consensus about the validity of that decision. And so we find, as a result of that process, our research has shown, lone actors emerge. This is exciting. It’s exciting not to the people who have suffered as a result of of these actors, but from a research perspective it means we’re in a better position if we understand this to help predict and proactively determine where and when new actors might emerge because we can just look at the nature of the discourse and measure that discourse to tell us where we believe an actor may become violent offline or not. And we have worked extensively in this area. We’ve been the recipients of several research grants. And we have produced evidence based on millions of online transactions in the public space and into some extent in the dark web where we’ve been able to track and read into the discourse analysis and develop some models and theories about how we might be able to better predict where and when social movements might become violent offline. And so that is part of what we do at CASIS and CIBC, as you know. So one of the things that I wanted to mention was we work extensively in the area of producing structured analytical technique workbooks for intelligence analysts and we throw up questions that might be useful for analysts to consider for their various cultural environments and operational tempo that they’re functioning within. But one area that is difficult is for an intelligence analyst or police analyst or public safety analyst to be able to keep track of all of these research trends and patterns and emerging developments. And so we found that there was a space in between using a structured analytical technique where you could evaluate some of your decision-making so that police and law enforcement action could be taken for a set of criminal behavior. We found that there was a big gap between that and an understanding of these new developing movements and trends and patterns and the new theories that are emerging from looking at social movements. And so what we’ve done is we’ve created a series of models which are effectively structured models and approaches and techniques that intelligence analysts may be able to use where we weave into the structured analytical techniques the modeling of the social movements or contemporary conflict and we layer these with the individual structured analytical techniques so that gives analysts the opportunity to have more contextually rich, less sterile, information available to help with decision-making. And when we are just variable focused, we tend to ignore the fact that they are dynamic characteristics involved in different spaces. And so these smarts help not only give a richer more contextually full assessment, but they also help with community impact assessment and reducing bias based assessment simultaneously. And so we’ve been moving at a pretty full pace at creating these, what we call, SMATs, so that policing and law enforcement can take these social movements and new conflict theories into account. Given that everything is evidence based, we’re very excited about these possibilities.
Natalie Archutowski (30:58): Once again a very thorough answer that has illuminated the need for my next question. We are almost out of time, so I would just like to ask one final question. From all the things you’ve touched on today, what are the three key takeaways that you think our audience should dwell on most and should help guide the way in which they move through this challenging new environment.
Candyce Kelshall (31:28): Good question. Off the top of my head, it will be that we should focus on science and knowledge and we should not be victim to peoples’ opinions and assumptions or anything that seems a little outrageous because it means it probably is. I think we should focus on science knowledge and try and find evidence for what people are saying before we simply just press like or press repeat because we’re building communities each time we take that action and we want to be sure that we’re in the right communities, communities which are based on sound information and not not assumptions. The second thing is to be resilient and adaptable. Change is going to be required. The way of behaving in the past that led to safety, security and affluence is not the way to safety, security, and affluence in this new environment. We can’t continue to do what we used to do. So we have to be adaptable and dynamic and think through ways of doing what we used to do differently but more importantly we need to be able to do that bearing in mind that our individual rights should not impinge upon our society’s rights to also have those same options available to them. So we can’t be selfish in this space. And you know I’d like to argue that in the past, being selfish is what allowed people to become rich and to have the luxury environments that we have been living in. We need to rethink those norms in society and I have nothing against personal affluence, don’t misunderstand me, I just mean that affluence must be something that we should understand, should not step on the rights of others, in the pursuit of affluence but rather we should ensure that our community is itself affluent not just financially but in safety as well.
Natalie Archutowski (33:28): Fantastic! Thank you so much for your time. Let’s pass it on back to our host Sarah Meyers. Those are some really insightful answers, thank you, Candyce.
Candyce Kelshall (33:41): You’re welcome.
Host Sarah Meyers (33:42): I’d like to close off Episode 1 of the podcast with a big thank you to our guests, Candyce and Natalie, for your insight that was a really interesting listen. Also a special thank you to production team Evan Pearce, Asmaa Patel, and David Henning. This has been the first episode of the Adversity Quotient podcast. We will be releasing new episodes every Monday with exciting guest speakers to keep you informed of the unfolding security environment. Thank you for listening and we will see you next Monday.
New episodes of Adversity Quotient are available every Monday! Follow @CASISVancouver for the latest news and updates.
Disclaimer: Views expressed are those of the speakers and do not necessarily represent those of CASIS Vancouver or any of its partners. Information given is not verified by CASIS or any third party acting on its behalf
